In my experience, people who use LLMs as educational tools... don't actually learn very well. They think they are, but they don't retain the knowledge nor do they seem able to infer from or apply the knowledge very well. There are even some early studies that are showing that using LLMs decreases cognitive ability, and considering how many kids and young people are using it to get their way though school and even higher education... I think we're using AI to raise a generation of stunted minds. That's going to be a bigger issue as time goes on and with the state of the world and who owns the LLMs... it looks like a grim, sad future thanks to this tech.
post
I loathe AI for multiple, personal reasons;
-
When I need to contact customer support of some sort, there is an AI bot that is no use and there are no real humans, because the AI is cheaper. I won't get the help I need or it's too difficult to reach.
-
My mother language is a bit more difficult one and many stores (especially online) are starting to translate everything with AI and that makes the text absolutely incomprehensible. Hard or even impossible to understand even the basic descriptions or the manuals.
-
Browsers have those forced AI-summaries when you try to look for something and those are often both wrong and impossible to turn off. (Or if it's possible to turn off, they keep turning back on.)
-
People I know are literally believing everything from those summaries and such and are very confidently wrong/misunderstanding whatever basic thing. It's very annoying. ("Let's ask STSÄTKEEPEETEE!")
-
Being parasocial online is becoming frustrating as I have been accused of being an AI bot on multiple occasions just because of the way I write in English. Knowing even basic grammar makes you a bot these days.
Kills the planet
Steals from artists
Widens inequality
Puts people out of work
Reinforces prejudices
Makes us stupid
Makes everything generic
Blows up the economy
Supports oligarchs
Can't be trusted, hallucinates and lies
Overhyped & overpromised
Can't generate outside of its training data
Is creating obscene surveillance state
Used in weapons to kill
Made computer components expensive
Ruined the internet with slop
Replaces human interaction
Just annoying
As a thought experiment I considered all of these points and here are my thoughts.
Kills the planet
Got me there. That stupid datacenter crap where they need 1000tb of ram and zillion 5090RTXs and an entire nuclear power plant just to generate a chocolate chip cookie recipe needs to fucking go. Self-hosted ai isn't that bad though. You can still argue that running a self-hosted koboldcpp on a 10 watt raspberry pi ALSO destroys the planet but so does all technology. Imagine living with no A/C, no deodorant, no running water, no toilet paper, just to make the earth livable for an additional 100 years or whatever. Fuck that. I chose to not have kids so I'm still doing my part which is more than what the majority of the population can be arsed to do.
Steals from artists
I don't really understand this argument despite being the most common anti-ai argument. What type of art is ai really capable of replacing humans on? Hentai and video game 3d model textures? It's useless at making 3d models even to the most fanatic of ai worshippers. I can watch porn on pornhub for free and would never and have never commissioned a human artist to make porn pictures for me. Am I stealing from hentai artists by not commissioning them for their work and choosing other means of looking at boobs?
Buying textures for your hand made 3d models only supports the corporation selling them and the original artists get very little if anything at all. Using ai to circumvent spammy price gouging for 3d model textures seems like a better way to fight back to me. Another point is that copyright trolls are always harassing random youtubers over bullshit claims which DOES destroy livelihoods. Using ai to create a unique illustration that isn't registered in a copyright strike database when you REALLY weren't going to pay a $20 license for some spammy corporate licensed art either way really seems like a legitimate use of ai to me.
Another thing is memes even. I would 100%, absolutely, positively, never ever in a million years commission a human artist for the hundreds of dollars it usually costs to make an illustration for a meme in a shitpost I was trying to make. Yet people get out their torches and pitchforks anytime someone uses ai in a shitpost. I just don't get it. It's the "pirating software STEALS money from developers" argument all over again. Is it REALLY stealing if you WEREN'T going to pay for whatever it was otherwise? In 2018 the average person online was practically up in arms over how unfair copyright law is and everyone dropped it to hate ai instead. Seems a little too convenient is you ask me. I think a lot of people have been played.
Widens inequality
Employers using ai to screen out the applicants that aren't desperate enough and are therefore less likely to submit to abnormally cruel or illegal terms could be an example of this. Employers in America generally have too many freedoms in the first place. We aren't going to get out this downward spiral of wages not keeping up with costs of living without doing some stuff that would be really unpopular to all the powerful people in charge of it all. I'm not sure that they need ai to continue colluding together to treat us all like trash. It will eventually devolve into all-out violence if no one forces them to stop ai or not.
Also facial recognition cameras, more about that further down.
Puts people out of work
I don't have any good supporting or opposing arguments for this one because I don't know of any strong examples. Ai is 1000% shittier than a human at any given task for 0% of the cost which is enough to keep an american corporation satisfied for most purposes at least in theory.
Reinforces prejudices
I'm not going to be like "provide examples or it doesnt count" because it's lame and stupid when people do that but my best guess for this one is its talking about how ai can be used to reinforce white nationalist ideology online in bot swarms and stuff. An ai can generate pro christo-fascist propaganda just as much as it can generate pro-democracy propanganda. I wish we could harass christian nationalist type people online with ai but it seems to be only the bad guys doing it. Go on reddit and say anything positive about marijuana in any context besides "my grandma is dying of cancer and marijuana allows her to not be in pain". You will have people telling you to grow up and stop being a piece of shit. Meanwhile, you can speak out in support of bombing poor people in the middle east and no one bats an eye. Why can't we harass the piece of shit people with ai? I guess you got me on this one. It only is used for spreading christian nationalist ideology for some reason. But this COULD change.
Makes us stupid
A few days ago I used a self hosted ai to help write a python script to run object recognition on the cctv cameras for my home network and it only took an afternoon. It would have taken longer to do this if I truly had to figure out and research every little detail and function name myself but I still could have done it. Sure there was some incorrect stuff in it but fixing that was still faster than doing it from scratch. I used the time I saved to also program a graph that shows the temperature history on my weather station. Does this mean I am stupid?
Makes everything generic
100% true. In 2014 or so, you could find anything you wanted on the internet. Now every single webpage is one big nothing-burger. Would corporate enshitification alone have brought things to this point even without ai? Maybe so, maybe not. The point stands.
Blows up the economy
It definitely provides a coverup excuse for the systematic price gouging of essential microchips and computer components, sure.
Supports oligarchs
This is true. Using non self-hosted ai even without paying for it does support oligarchs. Look at Grok for example. It's a blatant fascist ideology propaganda machine. The other bots probably do the same thing but more subtle. I bet if you asked chatgpt about marijuana, transgender rights or atheism it wouldn't be supportive of it. Yet if you asked chatgpt to run an online bot harassment campaign to tell transgender people and marijuana users how big of a piece of shit they are, there would be little pushback and it would say things of suspiciously higher quality than it was the other way around. They'd probably quietly and temporarily switch it over to the paid model for that one to make it generate higher quality hate speech without charging you for it. I'm not going to try it though.
Can’t be trusted, hallucinates and lies
Sure. You can't trust posts on the internet either. Sometimes I find it easier to do my research and differentiate between bad advice and not bad advice than it is to just start from nothing, but most of the seriously potentially useful stuff is usually banned from ai models anyway.
Overhyped & overpromised
I guess. See "Puts people out of work". 1000% worse for 0% of the cost is a no-brainer to an american corporation. To cut down on backlash they probably have to pretend replacing customer support roles with bots is "actually better".
Can’t generate outside of its training data
Some self hosted ai models are compatible with being connected to a websearch which means all the non-self hosted ones also have that. Then you have ai shifting through ai slop articles trying to guess which information is useful and which isn't. The thought of making an ai sift through another ai bot's poop is funny to me.
Is creating obscene surveillance state
This is the objectively worst part about the advent of ai. Ai powered facial recognition allows law enforcement to have an easier time tracking down and harassing the types of people that the dominant ideology (the christian nationalists) want removed from society. The fascists established a full-on 1984 and we fuckin' let them. For this one reason alone, I believe the world would be better of if ai were never a thing.
Used in weapons to kill
Violence wasn't invented until the first gun was invented after all. Not really. Maybe when the next american civil war happens, the good guys can have ai guided rockets or whatever too.
Made computer components expensive
I already elaborated on this, but yes. Spamming ai datacenters all over the place just to prevent houses from being built there to keep costs of living high means they have to fill them with overpriced video cards. To give credit where credit is due, this isn't all on ai. Chip companies are purposefully scaling back production so they can make more money while doing less work. Meanwhile, the government is massively cutting back on medicaid because they think we are all worthless losers who don't work hard enough and deserve to either die in prison over unplayable medical debt or live through suffering because there is lots of suffering in the bible and republicans want to make America more like the bible. It is an unreasonably cruel, unreasonably unfair double standard.
Replaces human interaction
I guess. Imagine getting swatted because you told your ai "friend" you were considering fleeing to a blue state and getting an abortion. Although religious fucknuts report their friends over this too.
Just annoying
If you get on any ai and give it a prompt like: generate a sensationalist shitpost of a news article titled "Why you should sell all your possessions and work 120 hours a week at your job instead and never take vacation because you deserve to live like that". The result is just an average modern news article.
Thanks for your reply. Here are my rebuttals:
Is AI killing the planet, or is capitalism and addiction to fossil fuels?
Capitalism was already killing the planet, but the rush to invest in AI has demonstrably accelerated it.
If AI was 100 renewable and run based on community consent, would it still be "killing the planet"?
No. But thats not the scenario we are in.
In what way does AI "steal" in any way more significantly than an artist uses another artist for inspiration or a coder uses another open source project for their code?
Because artists are people with consciousness and feeling and the capability for novel thought. AI is not. Believing it's doing the same thing as human thinking is being suckered by the hype.
Even the people creating AI know it's not "thinking". They call AI that actually "thinks" AGI and believe they will someday create it by pushing AI further, as long as we give them all of our money (trust me bro).
How does AI widen inequality worse than it has been already, and is that solely the result of AI or is it just a product of capitalism?
This is a big one, but without guardrails it's inarguably poised to hurt working people and enrich the powerful, which therefore drives further inequality (which yes, was already bad as a product of modern capitalism). And those guardrails are not in place, and will not be put into place if we just follow along as they want us to.
Because artists are people with consciousness and feeling and the capability for novel thought. AI is not. Believing it's doing the same thing as human thinking is being suckered by the hype.
But AI is being used as a tool by humans to generate the images. It won't do anything on its own.
What it has done is allow people to get inspiration out of their head and into the physical world with a much lower barrier for entry than ever before.
There are still people who don't consider digital artists to be real artists because they use digital tools instead of physical ones. The hate for people using genAI is basically the same thing.
There are a lot of valid criticisms of genAI, but this one in particular has always seemed silly to me.
If you tried to digest every piece of intellectual property ever created by humans for free, they would lock you up. But OpenAI and Meta get to do it, and sell you a subscription to the AI they created with it - Making Zuck and Altman richer than God by destroying the ability for artists to make a living, and making every bit of art created from now on a shitty derivative pasted together by an AI from the memory of human art. It's an episode of Black Mirror.
Not all genAI is OpenAI and Meta. There are ethically trained image generation models.
People are conflating all generative AI with tech giants, which is a critique on capitalism, not the technology.
The technology is actually quite amazing with regards to image generation.
Which ones are those?
The one Adobe offers is trained on licensed works.
Adobe? Ethical? What??
I feel this reply is somewhat misguided and reiterate many of the (frankly, a bit frustrating) AI propaganda talking point.
"It is not AI, it is capitalism": It is AI in capitalism, which is the reality we live in right now. If you take anything and put it in an utopia, then of course it will be great. But that simply is not the world we are living in.
Some people hate cars, because it is a inefficient, polluting, and unsafe way to travel. But what if cars are all running on renewable energy, is super small, and never collide with pedestrian or cyclist, then noone would hate cars!
Some people hate meat eating because it is inefficient and forces animal to live in inhuman conditions. But what if we can make animal photosynthesis and make them live happy, free, and full lives. Then no one will be against meat eating, but again, that is not our world right now.
Just because there is an alternative utopia where AI is perfect that doesn't mean it is right now, and its flaws causes the hatred on the internet.
Now, most AI center are polluting, consume large amount of energy, and those AI that people mostly uses are built with stolen knowledge. Finally, society should optimize for the well-being of the people, and artist are people, AI are not. All the AI people use nowadays funnels the money to the richest few, while majority of the population, even AI experts, don't have the means to train useful AI model as of now.
It's burning the environment down, destroying the shambles of the global economy, and being constantly shoved down everyone's throats even though it's only impressive to people who don't understand it
Reading through this thread and your responses gives the strong impression that you just want to argue while at the same time aren't very well informed on the matter. Where you do respond its mostly whataboutism rather than actually addressing the comment you are responding to.
Your post asks "Why do people hate AI?" and then goes on to validates many of the commonly heard reasons people have for hating AI. You end with a suggestion that if we could develop AI into something else in the future, it might be good.
So it seems you already understand why people hate AI and are promoting an agenda rather than asking a genuine question.
I do have an agenda, which is to try to understand...
If your goal is to understand why people feel the way they do then why are you arguing with people and attempting to refute their responses instead of thoughtfully reflecting their concerns back to them to confirm if you have understood?
You're being disingenuous because that's the only thing you're doing. You show no signs of actually ingesting or contemplating other points of view, opinions, etc.
For those who have been extra pedantic and focused more on the semantics of the arguments (i.e, you)
I've had 2 comments not including this one, neither of which discussed semantics. You never responded to my other comment.
Overall though, I have not called anyone derogatory names (unlike others in this thread)
While yes, that would indicate bad faith, never said you did that. Can't speak to others, who shouldn't do that.
I have not dismissed someone’s ideas out of hand without providing sources or examples, and I feel I have engaged in a respectful and calm manner.
It's less that you are dismissing things or being disrespectful. It's that your engagement has a pattern where you aren't engaging at all with certain points that is very obvious. Your positive bias toward LLMs shows. Whether it is due to legitimate bias or stark contrast within the thread due to a very polarizing topic is tricky to parse but definitely comes off that you are invested in LLMs and are unwilling to acknowledge the downsides in a meaningful way. E.g. your outright dismissal of the lack of ethics because it doesn't offend you personally and find those that complain to be hypocrites.
Sorry if my approach has not been what you would have preferred, but to be honest, given that you have not actually contributed to the discussion meaningfully, I frankly don’t give a shit.
Again, do you think you're responding to someone else? I rattled off a pile of common complaints to which you never responded. At no point did I accuse you of anything or even remark upon your character directly other than observing the stated pattern of avoidance and deeming it disingenuous. One inference could possibly be made with my rebuttal of your ethics argument, but it's kind of a stretch.
Are you saying I am being disingenuous in my intentions by making counter points in a discussion?
Yes, that's very clearly what's happening here.
In what way is making a counter point disingenuous?
It reveals that your intent is not to comprehend another perspective, but to insist upon your own.
Why do I need to just blindly accept what someone says without any pushback?
The thing that you're being asked to accept is that this someone believes what they say they believe.
Nobody's asking you to blindly assume that this someone is being honest, but making a counterpoint is not the same thing as asking clarifying questions to better understand their perspective or probe it for the inconsistencies that would indicate deception.
Imagine a shitty robot was just made available for free.
The shitty robot replaces you at work. It performs way faster with worse results, but the company hires a robot "expert" that fixes the results just enough that the product appears to be working. (Its not). You are now starving.
The shitty robot tells your kids that porn is a viable career path. And that they should kill themselves.
The shitty robot starts showing up everywhere, in advertising, TV shows, customer support lines, schools.
The shitty robot makes shitty art really fast, which people can sell or use how they want. Artists are now starving.
Imagine the shitty robot is now interviewing you for your next job.
Think of how shitty and scam filled the early internet was. Did we abandon it because of how shitty it was at first,
It wasn't though... That was mid to late term internet
Think of how shitty and scam filled the early internet was. Did we abandon it because of how shitty it was at first, or did we develop it and tweak it to it's full potential?
I have been on the internet since 1992, and the internet today is by far the shittiest and most scam infested it has ever been in my time (and I doubt it was worse in the 80s)
Few things make me more depressed than thinking about the evolution of the internet, from where it started to where it is today.
I don't doubt AI will follow a similar path, except somehow it is already starting in a much worse place than the internet ever did, and the downside potential is far greater and terrifying.
We did exactly the opposite of what you say, we monitized the scams and turned to entire internet into an scam-ad infested wasteland of the greed of 10 people at the cost of driving the rest of humanity to mindless addictions, grooming, and manipulating human psyche to eek out more money and mass-propagandize.
The majority of the internet is 10x worse than it was 20 or 30 years ago and there are literally more bots than people, according to research.
This clearly shows that you are willing to talk out of your ass. The early Internet was filled with some of the smartest people alive, the mass of shitty content did not arrive yet because it wasn't accessible to the masses. At the beginning, the Internet was literally only scientists. A little later, it was only very open people not scared to try something new and excited about the future and about foreign cultures, with corresponding amazing content.
Only after this initial period, when the internet became commonly used, did it turn shit. Stop trying to manifacture arguments for your position and truly do what you acted like setting out to do, try to be open and try to understand other people's concerns.
I didn't even make any argument for or against AI, just an argument regarding your behavior.
The early days of "AI" were a full generation before the beginning of the internet, as it was formalized as an academic field back in the 50's while ARPANET didn't start admitting non-Defense users until the 80's.
It will change society. It won't improve skills.
Studies already show the opposite at play. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2506.08872v1
If the LLM could teach you how to code, but couldn't do the coding for you, it would be a tool for improvement. But it isn't used that way. Instead of saying "teach me how to code this", people are more inclined to say "code this for me".
On top of that, they're controlled by corporations who are not in the slightest bit interested in your welfare, privacy or economic success. They will invade your privacy, fuck over the environment, fuck over people and load their LLMs with propoganda and barriers that serve their political and social interests.
And as a bonus, they're a nightmare for the environment.
Having said all of that. I agree, they are going to fundamentally reshape society. But it's like the industrial revolution. Yeah, we ended up with a more efficient society, but it didn't make people freer, it further entrenched wealth in the hands of the wealthy, whilst fucking up the environment. That's what LLMs are going to do.
We could do them differently. That implementation isn't inherent in their nature. But we won't do them differently, because the people pushing it want the shitty outcome, because it's not shitty for them.
AI makes children stupid. AI is mostly used for making AI slop. AI is being used by governments to manipulate public perception. AI is being used to engage is scams. People are using it to cheat. AI is being used to offset critical thinking.
AI is being used by corporations to engage in mass layoffs to save a buck. AI is being used by police stations and federal agencies to identify people, with minimal success (misidentification). AI is being used to deny health claims without review. AI customer service is dogshit.
I was a futurist like you once. I wanted AI based on how the movies presented it. However, the reality is LLMs are being used not for human improvement, but instead for the purpose of creating a permanent underclass with few at the top.
TL;DR: fuck AI.
Well, you dismissed the lack of ethics of it all. Just because you do open source doesn't mean everyone else does. And open source often acknowledges contributors, unlike LLMs. You can't consent for other people.
It's hideously destructive. Wastes electricity, wastes water, plays merry hell with anywhere the damned data centers pop up.
It's unregulated and has already killed people. Multiple stories have come out where an LLM has encouraged suicide. Plus various dangerous outputs like the bleach as cake ingredient thing. Because...
It isn't intelligent, it's just a parrot. I'll start paying attention when it can successfully count letters in words. So would you trust a random parrot that told you about something you know nothing about?
It doesn't do a quarter of what it says. Translation should be its bread and butter and it can't really manage that. There's a reason the tech bros that hyped crypto are hyping this. Because they don't actually know what it can or can't do.
It's approaching max efficacy for current techniques. More data is better in machine learning, but it's finding the limit and it's way closer than the scammers want to admit.
It's destroying jobs before it can handle them. I've tried to use it before. I spent as much if not more time fixing its output than if I had done it myself. It gets to do my boilerplate sometimes now.
It's making worse workers. All that time agonizing over a problem was spent learning how to do it at all. Now it shits out worthless garbage that the person doesn't know what it does or how to fix it. Job security for me I guess.
It could be a useful technology, but the delusion that it's capable of becoming AGI distracts from all the things it could be capable of if big companies actually tried to use them instead of the lazy implementations they're chasing.
Edit: I also forgot that it entrenches racism and other bad behavior. If your corpus is full of racist shit, you get a racist robot. And racist assholes make it harder to fix that because they won't acknowledge that such things are bad and that this badness can be taught* to robots.
Source: Data engineer
I have split opinions on it. The massive data centers that use so much power, hardware, space, etc are problematic. They get used as a replacement for human ingenuity, scarf down every bit of data the can, aggregate it together in a way that even the owners don't fully understand. They get manipulated to give answers that suit the owner's wishes and fuel divisions in public discourse.
I take significantly less issue with locally run small model systems that you can put on your own machine. They're not continually running/training and are generally treated more as a hobby toy, not some replacement for human understanding.
top 59 comments