If ATCs strike right now, what could they even do? They can't possibly bring on enough scabs to do the job. If they tried, it'd be a disaster and ensure US air travel dies.
Hey, Air Traffic Controllers! You have immense power right now!
If ATCs strike right now, what could they even do? They can't possibly bring on enough scabs to do the job. If they tried, it'd be a disaster and ensure US air travel dies.
Hey, Air Traffic Controllers! You have immense power right now!
Just wait till holiday season!
But the upshot is that commercial airlines heavily fund Republicans. So if they start having issues, they'll start letting their Republican folks know about it.
No. They’ll just get a bailout and we’ll go even further into debt.
My guess is the holidy season is when things start to ignite. That's when stress on the system hits the maximum, and when people start to realize that people who can barely afford food and shelter can't afford to do anything for the holidays. It will be hard to hide the recession at that point.
America's doing real great right now.
Can you order them back to work and then not pay them?
We even have a word for this: slavery.
Which is illegal in the US, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted.
And since they made it illegal for ATC to strike...
In theory, I guess, but that can only go wrong with a highly technical job like ATC.
There's a lot of things they could try on paper. All of them result in disaster. Not necessarily even planes hitting each other. Just one hub airport coming to loggerjams on the runway would be enough to have repercussions on the entire US airport network.
Yes, although ATC controllers have a lot of tools to not be working traffic
If a controller states they're too fatigued to work traffic, they must be given other duties, if available. They're given heavy legal protections to be able to say: I don't feel safe working traffic today. Bit of a counter balance to the fact they're basically slaves in regards to other worker protections
they would have to use force, they can try otherwise, it will just push them to quit. certain countries like australia is looking for ATC if things get to worst/.
No way am I flying in US airspace. This is just the latest in a series of major issues.
international airlines flights will mostly reroute around the USA, if they havnt done it already.
The primary result of this is primarily delayed or cancelled flights. Safety hasn't been significantly affected, although controllers are human and susceptible to human factors such as stress or fatigue that they may feel more pressure to work through than normal
https://www.reddit.com/r/ATC/s/K9KxRNLr0k
Safety is absolutely being impacted.
Anyone that says fire striking ATC's like Reagan did in the 80s. The 90s was when cheap domestic and international flights really took off along with businesses going international going full bore. Compared to the 80s, the economy is far more dependent on air travel and that disruption to shipping activity is what would end the shutdown.
A lot more ATCs are needed today compared to the 80s and the military shifted to less in volume but more expensive (supposedly higher quality that makes up the difference in quantity) military. Military ATCs don't have the numbers to replace regular ATCs
Could they even shift over the ATC from the military? I feel like the air base near me is even more active then ever these days.
They could as long as the US doesn't get into a very major war that requires a huge amount of logistics for overseas equipment and personnel. Can't do it for long because of how many military bases are overseas. Maybe you're seeing traffic related to Venezuela and the hurricane. Regardless it's just not enough people. The military doesn't staff as much as they used to, don't operate as much aircraft like they used too (though it's all much more expensive even inflation adjusted).
I can see them shifting military ATC's to airports and having airports restrict flights down a lot to favor flights carrying commercial cargo. If you're flying somewhere and there's enough cargo space expected for FedEx, USPS, UPS to pay to jam some cargo in there, good. If not, shit out of luck. FedEx, UPS, USPS, DHL, etc - their planes probably get scheduled with priority
how billionaires and millionaires travel if all airport shut down?
We're proceding very quickly to the find out phase. Republicans can stop this any day by changing senate rules or even forcing chuck schumer to speak for 48 hours instead of allowing a silent fillibuster. Schumer wouldn't last very long on a podium.
My guess is they don't want a real fillibuster because people would just read the republican budget out loud.
I’m sure they are fine with this. They probably want it. Don’t have to pay them. Plus more control over the people. I’m sure they will have coverage for their private jets and those of their friends.
There is really no mechanism for their private jets to have traffic coverage that wouldn't be given to other air traffic
The American air traffic system has a rather egalitarian design that I'm a big fan of. By and large traffic is treated equally. I, in a small GA plane, can fly into nearly* any civilian airport just like a private jet or commercial airliner. Air traffic control is a public service provided for free to anyone that needs it. A good example of where socialism has worked well
*There are some minor exceptions, for example LAX requires prior authorization for unscheduled GA aircraft at the moment. That and ATC may make a GA aircraft wait for a while before sequencing, but that's mostly a practicality issue, since they need to give a small plane a lot more time to land and space to avoid wake turbulence
The American air traffic system has a rather egalitarian design
Disgusting. Unacceptable. They ought to work on that.
See, does that go far enough?
If I'm letting someone out on my commute, a factor is how many people are in the vehicle. If it's a bus, they automatically get courtesy as who am I to delay 50 people to save myself 10 seconds.
ATC should be the same with private jets - they only get a slot once all the bigger planes have landed
all 96 comments