
post
This is basically the plot to Alien Earth.
inseparable
Is this a dig at pitbulls?
Yes, it is and people are assholes.
Yes, pit bull bites are more dangerous. No, that doesn't mean they should all be euthanized. They need proper training and that's it.
You're missing the blindingly obvious solution that should be taken: spay and neuter them so that no new ones are bred.
Or, ya know, people could be responsible pet owners.
If we could rely on every member of any sizable group of people to all reach even the lowest bar of decency, the world would be a very different place. Any solution that relies on the idea of "if everyone just does x" is not a real solution, as much as I'd like it to be.
No amount of responsibility can overcome what 200 years of artificial selection at a rate of every 2 years.
Responsibility includes accounting for possible aggressive behavior :/ If you're responsible for a chainsaw, you know to keep it oiled. You know to use it only in the correct environment, and you don't have it anywhere near children.
So yes, you can responsibly own a pitbull. Responsibility is being responsible for a subject; its well being, its actions, and the consequences of its existence.
And yes, responsibility can overcome what 200 years of artificial selection at a rate of every 2 years has done. That is literally what responsibility is charged with.
You're trying to twist and turn here. Accounting for? You can't overcome it. I say again, you can't overcome 200 years of artificial selection.
My aunt has lived with two pitbulls for almost a decade now. Raised two small children in the same home. Nothing but sweethearts. Dogs are individuals, just like people. Just like having another person around your baby, you need to be responsible with any dog breed.
It's about propensity, probability, likelihood, etc.
What's the margin? Where do we draw the line between breeds that are okay to allow to reproduce and which aren't? Pitbulls are statistically very safe, as all dogs are, when treated and trained well. If we banned everything with similar levels of risk of injury or death as pitbulls, we'd have to ban a LOT. Let's start with guns, cars, and hell, why not smoking and drinking for legal guardians of children, too. In-ground swimming pools can go, and let's revamp electrical outlets.
Obviously, it's a sliding scale of propensity, probability, and likelihood, as you said, but pitbulls are much lower on that scale. Just as with everything else on that list, the risk of harm to others, especially children, falls on the responsibility of the owner. This isn't to say "guns don't kill people, people kill people," as obviously guns enable easily killing many people quickly, but rather to contrast the realistic risk to family and community. Pitbulls have been excessively demonized for their relative risk. I can't take anyone calling for pitbull bans seriously unless they believe in authoritatively banning all the other aspects of our lives that pose similar levels of risk to ourselves and others.
I can't take anyone calling for pitbull bans seriously ...
You ask questions then rule out any answer* so I guess we're done .
(*technically unless it meets x y z.)
I would love to hear the argument for banning pitbulls despite being less risky than other commonly accepted risks.
In a hypothetical situation where every dog breed is banned except for Chihuahuas.
Would the amount of dog mauling be more, less or equal than how it is now?
If you say anything other than "equal" you agree that the breed is an aspect.
Those other risks are probably a lot more important to society than owning a specific breed of pet.
youre not going to get anybody to see the nuance. all pits bad 100%. even the good pits just didnt smell a good tasty kid yet. and the ones that did are just waiting for the perfect opportunity to strike. and also dont forget the racism involved with hating pit bulls
The nuance is that tons of "well trained" "family dog" pitbulls "that wouldn't hurt a fly" end up mauling someone to death because of their physical characteristics.
Racism has nothing to do with it.
You don't want to know how many "family dogs" like your aunts end up mauling people to death.
Every single one of them said their dogs were sweethearts and would never hurt fly. Now they are dead.
Yes, you can.
If it was about weeding out the fight drive of the dogs, a lot of things could be done, without the need to drive the breed to extinction. Inside the pit bull gene pool there are two lines: the fighting dogs and the bait dogs. The last ones are those that display the lowest drive for fighting and aggression. There is nothing wrong with these animals except their lack of will to fight other dogs and this trait makes these animals less desirable to people breeding these dogs that know they can make good money by keeping the fight drive of the breed. These are the people that often show off dogs hanging from ropes off the ground, growling and twisting on it, to showcase the bite force of the animals.
Increase the frequency of theses individuals in breeding pools, weed out the naturally more feisty, and you can modify the race or any race very fast. Pugs and Yorkshire Terriers area two examples that come to mind of breeds that suffered radical changes on very short time spans because of aesthetic trends. No obstacle on doing the same thing to improve a breed for good reasons instead of shallow ones.
There are a good number of breeds out in the world much more dangerous than the Pit Bull. The Tosa Inu, which was specifically bred to be a fighting dog, the Presa Canario, also bred for fighting, the Rodesian Ridgeback, and many others. In the 90's, Dobermans had the dirtiest reputation for being very dangerous. Nowadays, not so much.
So, your statement is misinformed.
note to mods: don't like what I wrote, just give me a permanent ban and be done with.
First I like that you acknowledge there is a fight drive.
Second, so you're discussing selective breeding to get it out, which is entirely different than people thinking you can coddle it out. You missed the entire conversation.
[...] you canβt overcome 200 years of artificial selection.
Is this you?
The way you put your argument, you seem to state there is no possible way to solve the issues this breed tends to show more propensity to exhibit. Selective breeding is one way and the best way to remove from the breed undesirable traits, as a root cause. But this does not mean it is the only one and extensive, structured, conscious training and conditioning, along with correct housing, can and will drastically reduce the risk of bad events. This breed is composed of individuals, which is often, conveniently, overlooked.
Pit Bulls are not exclusive to bad episodes with horrendous outcomes. Many other breeds are listed as controlled or banned, from country to country.
What Pit Bulls have against them that many have correctly stated is the tendency to attract the worst kind of humans.
Another breed are XL bullies. Pitbulls aren't the only dangerous dog.
Okay. Let's put things in order.
What exists, recognized by consensus, in objective terms and following scientifically verifiable conditions, is the definition of potentially dangerous breeds. These are breeds that, due to intrinsic physical characteristics can inflict serious injuries or cause death, in the event of an attack to others dogs or human beings.
In my barbaric country these breeds are, in alphabetic order:
-- American Staffordshire Terrier
-- Dogo Argentino
-- Fila Brasileiro
-- Pit Bull Terrier
-- Rottweiller
-- Staffordshire Bull Terrier
-- Tosa Inu
Along these, any cross between these breeds and between these breeds and others are automatically deemed as potentially dangerous. No dog is deemed dangerous because they are of one of these breeds; they are taken as having the potential to be and as such to have one, certain conditions must be met. Minors can not own one, no one under the age of 16 can walk one, the animals have to use a functional muzzle when in public spaces, the owners must not have criminal record and must obtain a basic certification from our police, where people are taught a bit more at length all that I have written here, along with some legislation and responsibilities. Oh, and the owner of a dog of one of these breeds must have a civil responsibility insurance.
In order for a dog to be deemed effectively dangerous, the dog needs to either attack or kill another dog, animal or human being *out of their home or property in a fashion that they were not provoked or act in defense of their family.
There have been a good number of dog attacks on humans on my country, a few by dogs of these breeds. When investigated, it is common to find out the dogs are either abused or mistreated, were conditioned to be aggressive or were never properly socialized and trained to model behavior. But as a last, anecdotal, thought: in my town, most dogs declared dangerous due to attacks on human beings are often under 10kg. Why? Because small dogs are cute. They are small, they can't/won't/never hurt no one. Then an unruly dog, used to get their way anyway, always, chomps someone's legs or ankle or hand and then all things go haywire.
You know where 95% of problems related to dogs usually start from? On the other end of the leash.
Based country. Euthanise them all I say.
Why? Why defend a blanket blunt solution after undergoing so much time to develop a proper, clear, definition to what a potentially dangerous animal is and what an actually dangerous animal is? Why label an animal as a danger just because it was born?
You don't educate humans, dogs get punished.
There is no good reason to own any of those breeds casually
Oh, I like that reasoning.
Shall we widen the lens then?
Dobermans, Boxers and Great Danes were viewed as dangerous breeds in the 90's. Belgian Mallinois and German Shepherds garnered a bad reputation due to their association with police and military forces. Catahoula Leopard Dogs have killed people in the US. Border Collies and Australian Cattle Dogs are well known to bite, particularly children, due to their herding background. Even Golden Retrievers and Labradors have been deemed dangerous at some point.
And then there are all the other breeds, less known, that have maimed or killed and never got any attention for it. And all the other breeds that are as powerful or more than the list I shared and just haven't met the criteria of having attacked someone and got the bad press. There are far more powerful dogs in the world than those in that list, breeds specifically developed to chase, hunt and/or fight other animals that are not in it. In Italy, one of my national breeds has been listed as dangerous and controlled; no such concern here as no bad episodes have occurred and we have a higher number of such dogs here, pure bred and crossed.
But you did said something correct: casually.
The biggest issue is most people never bother to properly care for their animal companions. They are pampered as puppies, while they are cute and docile, then more easily managed by being chained or confined to a back yard or a fenced area and overlooked. They become a nuisance, something that consumes time and energy, people say they "don't have".
That is what causes most of the problems regarding dogs.
Hol' up, there's some sort of incongruity here that I can't quite put my finger on...
You should be embarrassed to support eugenics.
r/whooooosh
Could you explain why you think they're not serious?
Unfortunately there is a feedback loop somewhere.
Pitbulls have a reputation for being dangerous tough guy dogs, so "tough guys" get pitbulls and proceed to not treat them well, this give pitbulls the reputation of being dangerous tough guy dogs.
I live in Copenhagen, however, and I've seen some very nicely treated pitbulls, even one that was part of a family. They can be so gentle.
So can guns.
Guns don't get old and have a bad day killing their owner. Pitbulls do unfortunately. I've seen good ones and bad ones but when they are hurting or just grumpy old farts they can go off. The difference between a shitzu and and pitbull doing that is the pitbull is powerful and the shitzu is annoying.
"heres anecdotal evidence to support my worldview"
Searching "pitbull kills baby" gets way too mant results for my liking
so does "golden retriever kills baby" or "insert any dog breed kills baby"
It's just less common compared to the relative popularity of the breeds
It literally doesnβt, please cite a single golden retriever kills baby article
https://howellinjurylaw.com/blog/newly-adopted-dog-kills-infant/
the point was that "too many results for my liking" doesnt mean anything unless there is a number greater than 0 that is to your liking in which case yikes
The one example you found came over a decade ago from a retriever mix in a household where a different unspecified dog later attacked another child. So on one side you have a single tenuous example from over ten years ago in a huge red flag environment, and on the other you have multiple pit bull fatalities this month.
lol, lmao even
Edit: itβs also worth noting that your cited example involved an infant child, who are the most vulnerable humans by far and could be at threat by basically any living entity. Whereas every pit bull example I listed above, again just from this month, involved fully grown adults.
Now hypothetically, if every breed except Chihuahuas was banned, and those tough guys were forced to buy those and not train them.
Do you think there would be more, less or equal amount of dog mauling?
Less. Chihuahuas can be aggressive, bitey little shits without proper training. Most people I've seen with Chihuahuas don't train them. It's just a small little dog, what harm can it do?
It doesn't matter about the mauling. What is more likely to kill you? A pitbull or a Chihuahua. If a Chihuahua tried to maul an average healthy adult, the healthy adult could probably fight it off quite quickly with minimal small bite injuries. You can't say the same about a pitbull.
That's exactly how everyone talks about their pitbull until it rips their child to pieces.
They need proper training and thatβs it.
Tuesday that 30-year-old (...) was found dead Monday night at a home near Newington from an apparent dog attack. (...) He says an autopsy revealed Wilcox died as a result of injuries received from the attack.
Investigators say Wilcox was familiar with the pets at that residence and had handled them safely on numerous occasions in the past. None of the dogs in the home had any known history of viciousness or aggression
Pitbulls are a breed designed to kill.
You can have a Border Collie and it will be shepherding sheep on a screen, or dust motes on the floor, because it's in their DNA.
Killing and aggression are in the DNA of Pitbulls.
Stop being weird.
This is it, full stop. Dogs are individuals and should be treated as such.
I helped raise and home two litters of Staffordshire pups, we kept a rigorous list of the owners that we interviewed and checked the homes once a year to monitor the dogs progression. We made the owners sign a contract stating that if the living standards weren't up to snuff, we could reclaim the dogs. I worked with a fellow who raised Staffies for 30 years. In two litters, we had around a dozen well trained, friendly huggable porkchops. Two litters that had no recorded bites past a few months old (puppys nibble but can be trained), and showed no aggression with other animals. All those pups lived to old age, and passed in happy homes. I've also met too many pitbulls that were beyond any help i had to offer. Damaged dogs damaged by poor parenting.
I know my story is anecdotal, and i don't expect to change minds here, but i cant stand the outrage against such lovable dorks when something like the chihuahua exists.
Dogs are animals, and no amount of training can make it certain they will not attack, because, as you say, they are individuals. Therefore a well-trained Pitbull remains more dangerous than a well-trained [insert literally any other dog breed here].
I absolutely love dogs, including Pitbulls. I despair at what humans have done with selective breeding, by giving Pugs a lifetime of health problems, Pitbulls a greater chance of being euthanised, greyhounds a brain the size of a pea etc., etc. The right thing to do is to vote with our feet and stop the demand for breeds that shouldn't exist. The real villains here are the people creating pure bred pits for profit.
Dogs aren't individuals. They're animals. You don't need a pitbull. There are plenty of other beautiful breeds like Retrievers/Laboradors or Border collies, etc.
With pitbulls you have to train them specifically not to fight to lower the chances. They shouldn't be available to own to the general public.
Humans are also animals. Part of the animalia kingdom, like everything else of flesh and bone.
Animals may not be sapient (being capable of human level generalist brain processing), but they're absolutely individuals with individual personalities.
You'd know this of you've lived with a few cats, or dogs, or worked on an animal farm for any length of time.
Yes, and humans also get judged based on their own actions.
You aren't going to lock up the parents of a serial killer because they didn't train them well enough.
Dogs are individuals as well. Some still show their wild instinct even when trained well enough. Or are you saying dogs can't have a personality?
They should all be euthanised. There's no good reason to own a pitbull. They were literally bred for fighting and it's in their instincts.
Should I go down the list of all the dogs that were specifically bred for being hunting dogs, war dogs, or guard dogs?
That list is absolutely going to be massive and I'm pretty sure it'll feature a number of dogs you'd otherwise consider lovable family dogs.
We're probably going to be left with a handful of breeds meant for puffed up rich floozies that suffer from amalgamated sinus cavities.
If you know what breed it's talking about, that suggests there's probably some truth to it
That's not a valid argument, since it can be used elsewhere. Using that argument would confirm any racist or sexist stereotype as well, since you know what they mean. Just because someone has heard let's see, that Jewish people are lizard aliens who drink blood and adrenochrome from babies doesn't mean there's some truth to it.
I'm not using the above as an argument against pit bulls having aggressive natures; I mostly stay out of that argument (though the one pit I remember was a lovely pup). I am saying that as an argument backing up the aggressive claim, it's a bad one to use.
Stereotypes about groups of humans are politically motivated. Not true of dog breeds.
You might want to adjust your thoughts on the second. Studies have shown that pit bulls are associated with black people, and that people who have unfavorable views of black people, especially as being violent, also have a correlation to negative views of pit bulls. You can find one such study here: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11213322/
Question: βIf you had to guess, do you think Black people or white people are more likely to own the following dogs?β Source: Pooled Lucid Surveys, June-July 2020, August 2021.
Not everyone dislikes based on racial association, but to claim there is none only illustrates that your argument is both invalid and uninformed.
Studies have shown that pit bulls are associated with black people, and that people who have unfavorable views of black people, especially as being violent, also have a correlation to negative views of pit bulls
Not OP, but - this has nothing to do with racism, WTF are you talking about?
"Studies have shown"... My god, studies have shown that a breed created for violence and bloodthirst has a higher probability of being violent and bloodthirsty than those that weren't, that's literally all the context there was!
You kneejerked answered without even reading the linked study, didn't you?
Of course I didn't read the study, because it's off topic.
Pitbull kills white dog trainer.
Pitbull of a black dog trainer kills another dog
Race of the human has nothing to do with the fact that the fucking dogs were designed to maim and kill, dude.
My comments and the links were all about the stereotypes part,not really the pitbulls. This particular comment reply chain, at least where I got involved, was just about how stereotypes alone isn't a basis for truth. A counter argument was made that such a judgement doesn't count for dog breeds, and the study shows that it indeed can count.
My comments and the links were all about the stereotypes part,not really the pitbulls
Exactly my point. Nobody is talking about any stereotypes.
A counter argument was made that such a judgement doesnβt count for dog breeds
If the discussion was about how "X people tend to get Pitbulls", I'd agree that talking about stereotypes makes sense.
But the discussion was about Pitbulls being bloodthirsty and dangerous. It's not a stereotype, it's a biological fact.
If you know what breed it's talking about, that suggests there's probably some truth to it
This is the comment where this particular comment chain veered into the subject of stereotypes. Chatokun correctly pointed out that this is a specious argument because it can also be applied to racial stereotypes.
So your statement, "Nobody is talking about any stereotypes", is untrue.
That may be true in the US. Here in the UK there is no such correlation, and yet pitbulls here still cause more injuries and deaths than all other breeds combined. Odd, that.
My argument wasn't that it cancels out any studies showing pitbulls being aggressive; as I stated before, I wasn't interested in participating in that argument. My argument was that stereotypes aren't a valid argument that something is true. They then stated that dogs aren't political, u like other stereotypes to which I demonstrated that yes, dogs breeds can be associated with political biases. I
Do you think that stereotyping applies here, then? You seem minded to agree that pitbulls are more dangerous in fact than other breeds, given you won't participate one way or the other. So if pitbulls are in fact more dangerous then if would be reasonable, rather than irrational stereotyping, to be more wary of them, and to label them as more dangerous.
"If you had to guess" sounds like you are relying on hearsay there bud
Well racism and people's perception of stereotypes often aren't backed up by actual statistics.
The study isn't saying pitbulls are more often owned by black people, it says people think that to be the case regardless of evidence.
It'd be like a study asking what race you think are the worst drivers, even if "most" people say "Asian" because of the common trope, it doesn't mean that is true statistically, it just means that stereotype is commonly believed by the study's participants.
Why are you comparing Jewish people to dogs????? That's a bit antisemetic
Question is to what extent it is the breed versus the owners drawn to or scared away from the breed. These things can be self fulfilling.
I kinda feel like the xenomorphs could be not domesticated but maybe appeased for lack of a better word. They don't like being held captive, and they are vindictive as shown by Resurrection. But it also showed them to be intelligent. If you gave them things to eat/implant with eggs enough to satiate them, perhaps they would think of you as a pet and leave you alone.
Ehhh they're an invasive species with a parasitic larval stage, we're fucked. The more we appease the more their numbers grow and the less likely we are to be able to satiate them, much less them and any sizable human population (though there wouldn't be a sizable human population very long).
"One" question (ok one multi-part question), does anyone have data on the life cycle? How long until eggs hatch, how long in larval stage, how long until the little guy that bursts out becomes an H. R. Geiger penis monster, how many eggs can those penis monsters lay per day, and how many calories do they need for their daily intake?

top 100 comments