I’ve mixed feelings on it. On one hand I feel the game is really overpriced given how old it is and how barebones the port is, and I feel 30 bucks is still a bit much.

On the other hand, if this is your first time playing the game, there IS a lot of content there. It’s a fairly big game to stick your teeth into. Ignoring its age and status as a port, I can see an argument for $30 being valid based on content. But I feel this should be its full price.

If I hadn’t already completed it on PS3, I’d buy it now at this price. I don’t think rockstar is likely to discount it further.

Rockstar are greedy bastards so just pirate

You could probably buy a 360 or ps3 and a copy of the game for that price!

If you don't want to spend the 30, just wishlist it and wait to pounce while you play something else. It's not going anywhere unless you are.

I think that depends more on your income level. Is $30 a lot to you?

It's about £22 to me and whilst I'd say the game is a lot of fun (I played through it in 2019, I think, on my Xbox One X) I personally wouldn't pay that much for it. However I spent a long time poor, so I'm rather price sensitive even though I probably don't need to be quite so hesitant any more.

A lot of reviews on Steam address this exact question, read them. Ultimately, it's down to your taste. RDR1 is a notable step down compared to RDR2 for quite obvious reasons, so see it for yourself whether you're ready to deal with an Xbox 360 era game.

I believe it's a fair price. The game is old now, but it's still the same game. It was worth $50 (or was it $60?) when it was released, and it's worth $30 now, IMO.

I have been brainwashed about old game prices by Nintendo though, so not sure if everyone will agree with this 😀

If you buy it legit on Steam it will force you to install the Rockstar launcher in order to actually play it. It is not known to me if there is a workaround, because of reasons completely unrelated to Captain Jack Sparrow.

After almost finishing part 2 I'm interested in how the story continues. But I'm happy to wait until they drop the price to a reasonable amount (< 15 €), even if that time may never come.

I personally prefer RDR1 to RDR2. $30 is a little high for game that old, I think $20 is the sweet spot. RDR2 has too much filler for me, which seems to be Rockstars MO in recent years. RDR1 is more straightforward with just the right amount of side quests thrown in.

After resisting at first, I started listening to the RDR1 soundtrack again recently and then the nostalgia became so strong I just had to buy it. I bought the Switch cartridge from Amazon for £30 a few days ago.

Is it a fair price? Not really. Is it a game I don’t expect a heavy discount on any time soon because it’s Rockstar? Yes. Am I enjoying playing again, at way higher resolution and clarity than it ever was on PS3? Absolutely.

It’s actually a better port than I was expecting, and much more of an upgrade than I expected from PS3.