If you don't know the real cause of a disease or condition, you cannot properly treat it. Worse still, if you get the cause wrong, the treatment will be wrong as well, and you won't be looking for the cure in the right direction. This is what doctors have been doing for thousands of years, since Hippocrates, and it's what we need to do again now.
"Let for be thy medicine, and medicine thy food."
generated summary
Nutrition as medicine and root causes
- Nutrition has a long history in medicine, including more than a century of ketogenic diets for epilepsy and several centuries of meat-centred, carbohydrate-restricted diets.
- Thomas Sydenham's seventeenth-century dietary guidance for diabetes and other illnesses used veal, mutton and similar meats, exclusion of fruit and garden produce, and minimal carbohydrates. [1]
- William Osler, the first professor of medicine at Johns Hopkins, included that approach in The Principles and Practice of Medicine; Chaffee inherited a 1900 edition from his surgeon great-grandfather. [2]
- The older medical approach sought the cause of illness and its reversal or cure, in contrast with ongoing drug-based symptom control and disease management.
Osler on diabetes
- Osler's diabetes chapter identifies diabetes as a disease of nutrition and uses Sydenham's meat-focused dietary approach for disease reversal. [1][2]
- In Osler's adult-onset and juvenile-onset categories, which preceded the type 2/type 1 distinction, adults had substantial improvement or remission on the diet.
- Before insulin, juvenile diabetes still had high mortality, but all patients had longer survival on Osler's diet, some lasting nine months to a year or more; the long-term survivors are the basis for an inference of remission.
Autoimmune disease and plant lectins
- Autoimmune activity may involve an immune response to harmful compounds such as plant lectins, as explored in D. L. Freed's publications from the 1980s onward. [3][4]
- J. H. Salisbury's roughly thirty-year investigation of diet and illness included meat-only dietary care for rheumatoid arthritis and severe intestinal illnesses now known as Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis. [5]
- Plant lectins are defensive compounds with immune-stimulating and tissue-damaging activity, recognized in research dating to the 1970s; the resulting immune activity may be a response to an external insult.
- An autoimmune diagnosis directs attention to immune suppression, while dietary exposures may remain an underlying source of damage.
Type 1 diabetes: literature and longer-term observations
- Two published cases of type 1 diabetes involved eating fatty meat without plant foods or carbohydrates, following the earlier dietary approach. [6][7]
- Osler's meat-based diet used approximately equal grams of fat and protein; later, higher-fat versions were used in the 1920s with improved outcomes. [2]
- Both published cases involved normal blood glucose without injected insulin and recovery of endogenous insulin production to normal levels. [6][7]
- The author of the two published cases has fifteen years of similar clinical observations, with the greatest chance of insulin-free remission within the first year after diagnosis and recurrence following dietary departure.
- Nearly everyone can lower insulin requirements on this diet even without insulin independence; one exceptional recovery occurred around fifteen years after diagnosis.
- Type 1 diabetes antibodies target insulin-producing beta cells but not their precursor stem cells; remaining stem-cell capacity may permit renewed beta-cell production after damaging exposure ends.
Two cases from clinical experience
- Two newly diagnosed type 1 diabetes cases in Chaffee's clinical experience involved ketoacidosis, thirst, frequent urination, rapid loss of roughly twenty to thirty pounds, undetectable insulin and C-peptide, and positive antibodies.
- Blood glucose was unstable during insulin use alone; on a meat-only diet, glucose stabilized, insulin requirements fell, and C-peptide became detectable after approximately six weeks.
- Within three months of diagnosis, both patients had stopped injected insulin and had HbA1c of 4.5, after initially having no detectable endogenous insulin production.
- One patient resumed other foods during work travel, lost glucose control and needed insulin again; after three months back on the diet, he was insulin-free with HbA1c again at 4.5.
How diabetes care changed
- Post-insulin editions of Osler's text retained dietary care first, with insulin introduced after six or seven days without adequate glucose control and used cautiously because excessive doses can cause dangerous hypoglycaemia. [2]
- From the 1950s and 1960s, concerns about meat, fat and heart disease shifted dietary advice toward more carbohydrates and away from the earlier dietary approach.
- During the Nixon era, surplus government-purchased wheat and a desire to increase grain consumption drove dietary guidance from researchers' three or four servings to nine to twelve servings.
- With higher-carbohydrate dietary guidance, nutritional glucose control became less effective, while pharmaceutical management of type 1 and type 2 diabetes grew into a financially self-sustaining system.
Celiac disease and the immune response
- Celiac disease is classified as gluten-mediated autoimmunity; removing gluten stops intestinal injury and enables healing even with antibodies and immune cells elevated for more than three years.
- The immune response in celiac disease is tied to gluten-associated injury, with ongoing damage dependent on gluten exposure.
- Gluten binds to intestinal cells, makes them adhere to one another, and damages them, with the resulting immune response varying between individuals.
- Gluten-associated damage can induce intestinal cells to display MICA, a stress signal marking them as compromised and activating immune-cell destruction. [8]
- Similar mechanisms may apply to other autoimmune conditions; Freed linked particular plant lectins with particular diseases, and removing the relevant exposure could end tissue injury. [4]
Exposures, nutrient deficiencies, and health
- Chronic diseases arise from combinations of harmful exposures and inadequate nutrition, with this causal model forming the subject of Chaffee's developing book.
- Exposures include food compounds, environmental factors, radiation and excessive screen use; screen use affects neurodevelopment and attention, while Chaffee experienced reduced sustained concentration and reading after social media use.
- Nutrient deficiencies can be missed when laboratory normal intervals are based on local population averages, vary by laboratory, and reflect populations with illness or nutrient deficiencies.
- Research on optimal vitamin and mineral levels, including magnesium sufficient for enzymatic reactions, concerns levels associated with health beyond population averages; correcting exposures and deficiencies addresses root causes.
References
- [00:41] The Whole Works of Thomas Sydenham — https://wellcomecollection.org/works/ax9ewmd9
- [01:21] The Principles and Practice of Medicine — https://wellcomecollection.org/works/pvb2tsbg
- [06:02] Lectins — https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.290.6468.584
- [06:02] Do dietary lectins cause disease? — https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.318.7190.1023
- [06:25] The Relation of Alimentation and Disease — https://wellcomecollection.org/works/qeybadm7
- [09:50] Type 1 diabetes mellitus successfully managed with the paleolithic ketogenic diet — https://doi.org/10.5348/ijcri-2014124-CR-10435
- [09:50] A child with type 1 diabetes mellitus successfully treated with the Paleolithic ketogenic diet: A 19-month insulin freedom — https://doi.org/10.5348/ijcri-2015121-CR-10582
- [20:06] A Direct Role for NKG2D/MICA Interaction in Villous Atrophy during Celiac Disease — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2004.06.018
no comments (yet)