Amber O'Hearn's discovery of the carnivore diet to address her weight loss stall on the keto diet. Not only did her weight normalise again, but she also noticed her depression and other psychiatric problems not only improved, but cleared up completely. So instead of reverting to the ketogenic diet after her weight came back down, she has remained on the carnivore diet for about the last 10 years now and is absolutely thriving!
generated summary
Why I adopted carnivore
- Low-carb eating began in 1997 for weight control, but after about 12 years, pregnancies and antidepressant use coincided with renewed weight gain.
- Weight gain continued despite a low-carb diet that had previously worked.
- In late 2008 a small online "zero-carb" community shared experiences of renewed weight loss after eliminating plants when low-carb alone had stalled.
- "Zero carb" is imprecise: animal foods can contain trace carbohydrates, while carb-free canola oil is outside carnivore.
- The all-animal trial was initially intended to be temporary for weight loss before returning to low-carb.
- Depression, later re-diagnosed as a form of bipolar disorder, came to a standstill after plant elimination; the psychiatric improvement sustained carnivore eating.
Why elimination can become a lifestyle
- Elimination diets often start as temporary trials with foods added back to identify problems; Georgia Ede and Steven and Melody are examples from the conversation.
- Carnivore initially seems highly restrictive, but improved well-being can remove the desire to resume previous eating habits.
- Food choices balance the best attainable health with enjoyment.
When to be strict and when to reintroduce foods
- Doug's partial carnivore "ketovore" pattern includes occasional avocado and macadamia nuts; some strict groups exclude even spices.
- A meaningful elimination trial can involve about one month of strict carnivore, or three to six months in other approaches, before evaluation.
- Eating plants such as avocados during the trial makes the effects of full plant elimination harder to isolate.
- After a strict baseline is established, reintroduced foods can be assessed for effects; unchanged well-being permits inclusion, while adverse effects create a personal pleasure-versus-cost decision.
- After an initially strict phase, occasional 100% chocolate, pickles and wasabi with sashimi caused no noticeable changes.
- A psyllium-husk self-experiment on appetite suppression from extra fiber was followed immediately by a severe psychiatric episode, leading to psyllium avoidance.
- The potential mental health cost of a setback is high, and the absence of cravings for salad reduces interest in testing more plant foods.
- Dietary purity has no moral reward or "badge"; strictness helps identify what works without conferring status.
- Ribeye every day remains enjoyable for many carnivores, so the diet need not feel restrictive in practice.
Nutrients, organ meats and vitamin C
- Nearly every essential nutrient is obtainable from animal foods, often in more usable forms than from plants; vegetables are not nutritionally necessary.
- Some nutrients are easier to obtain through organ meats such as liver, though individual preferences for organs differ.
- Vitamin needs derived from high-carbohydrate diets may differ from needs on carnivore; this remains disputed within the community.
- Vitamin C is easier to obtain from plants, but ribeye also contains enough to prevent scurvy.
- Doug's view is that ketosis may substantially lower vitamin C needs compared with standard RDAs; his household frequently eats liver, kidneys and ox heart.
Steak-only eating and long-term uncertainty
- Shawn Baker's planned three-month red-meat-only regimen excludes fish and organs during training to improve his indoor-rowing record, based on feeling strongest on steak.
- Some carnivores have followed a carnivore diet for ten or more years without organ meats or obvious difficulties; these experiences are anecdotal.
- A three-month steak-only period differs from long-term use, and folate or vitamin C depletion is not expected to be an immediate concern in that time.
- Long-term steak-only risks are unknown; choices include organ meats or supplements, reliance on experience, or later reassessment using symptoms and blood tests.
- Diet effects need monitoring, with changes when adverse effects emerge.
no comments (yet)