can individual biology shape whether a given diet or protocol actually works — or does one approach fit everyone? Craig Emmerich (co-author and nutrition researcher alongside Maria Emmerich) makes the case for bioindividuality in metabolic health, discussing his decade-long journey with chronic Lyme disease and ankylosing spondylitis, the protein-sparing modified fast as a weight-loss tool, a fat-cell–centric view of insulin resistance, oxidative priority of fuel sources, and whether AI may reshape personalized medicine.

generated summary

Engineering, Family, and the Low-Carb Business

  • Craig grew up in rural Medford, Wisconsin, studied electrical engineering at the University of Minnesota from 1990 to 1996, and worked at Honeywell on military helmet displays and the early Land Warrior system, then in chip-testing equipment and healthcare imaging software.
  • Craig and Maria grew up in the same town but met later. Maria had PCOS, reflux, IBS, and weight difficulties despite following the nutrition advice she learned in college; independent reading led her to low-carb eating and client coaching. Craig initially continued brewing beer and eating as before because he had no pressing health problem.
  • Craig lost his engineering job during the 2007 financial crisis while the couple were adopting two sons from Ethiopia. A friend's idea to sell Maria's recipes led to a self-published cookbook that funded continuation of the adoption, and word of mouth gradually built their business without paid advertising.
  • Maria developed recipes and ingredient changes while Craig maintained the website, publishing, finances, and eventually studied biochemistry and wrote the scientific chapters. He left engineering when the nutrition business could support them; their later book, The Art of Metabolic Health, combines both of their work. [1]
  • Maria coauthored The Ketogenic Cookbook during the early low-carb, high-fat movement, and the couple subsequently wrote books with more emphasis on protein. [2] Craig's initial explanation of insulin resistance leaned heavily on the carbohydrate-insulin model; his view later changed.
  • Through low-carb conferences Craig met Dave Feldman and other engineers. Dave launched his Citizen Science Foundation study at Low Carb Houston in 2019 [3], and his first documentary interviews began during a January 2020 trip that started in Beijing; footage later entered The Cholesterol Code. [4]
  • The engineering approach begins with the complexity of metabolism and differences between people. No single diet or intervention fixes every condition, despite pressure within parts of the carnivore community for one universal solution.

Chronic Lyme, Pain, and the Limits of Diet

  • An old football injury made recurring back pain seem routine for Craig. About a decade ago the pain began spreading slowly through his spine, shoulders, and neck; migrating knee, ankle, and hip pain eventually made normal movement difficult.
  • Craig suspected Lyme disease, but a conventional Western blot was negative. He estimates that 70–80% of these tests can give false negatives, partly because of the limited bands tested and absent screening for tick-borne coinfections; a later, expensive expanded panel detected Lyme and at least one coinfection.
  • Prolonged infection and immune activation coincided with Craig's ankylosing spondylitis, which damaged and fused parts of his spine and neck. Lyme, mold exposure, and heavy metals complicated the illness, and he connected the persistent inflammation with chronic inflammatory response syndrome, or CIRS.
  • Already heavily meat-based, Craig adopted fully carnivore after learning how Charlene Anderson used it for Lyme-related pain. Removing the remaining plants reduced his pain further but did not eliminate the infection or reverse the structural damage.
  • Craig used the Cowden herbal protocol for over nine months, antiparasitic drugs, multiple other approaches, and three simultaneous antibiotics for about nine months, with little lasting benefit. People with similar illnesses responded differently to the same therapies.
  • Some interventions brought severe symptom flares interpreted as Herxheimer reactions. Glutathione patches, for example, left Craig nearly bedridden; such fluctuations made it difficult to distinguish useful interventions from aggravations.
  • Addressing mold through a CIRS protocol helped substantially, and hyperbaric oxygen helped with pain. Lowering symptoms with diet or supportive therapies and eliminating the underlying source of illness are different outcomes.
  • At Craig's worst, even roughly a quarter-cup of coleslaw seemed to trigger 24–36 hours of extra joint pain. He saw plant antinutrients as an additional burden on an already overloaded immune system; this sensitivity was individual and did not establish a universal need to avoid plants.
  • Pain eventually consumed family life and work, and cold weather sometimes left Craig using crutches indoors. Imaging found his left hip bone-on-bone with spurs and a cyst; total hip replacement about two years before the interview reduced pain within a week. He had the right hip replaced about five and a half weeks before the interview, at an earlier stage of deterioration.
  • Chronic pain dominated Craig's waking decisions. He continued searching for answers, but surgery, not more restrictive carnivore eating, relieved the worst mechanical hip pain; once pain eased, he rapidly stopped daily pain medication.

Protein Priority and Protein-Sparing Modified Fasts

  • Maria's original approach included pure-protein days to overcome weight-loss stalls. The couple briefly followed the high-fat emphasis of early ketogenic publishing, but returned to protein priority when her own experience and client outcomes were less satisfactory.
  • A protein-sparing modified fast (PSMF) arose from attempts to preserve lean tissue during prolonged fasting. Fasts lasting several days produce urinary nitrogen losses as the body supplies needed glucose through glycerol and amino acids; dietary protein can spare some body protein while retaining rapid fat loss.
  • PSMF entails deliberately high protein with very little carbohydrate or dietary fat. It is a temporary weight-loss tool, not a permanent diet: their approach uses one to three PSMF days per week and sometimes an additional maintenance-calorie or overfeeding day.
  • In one example, 150 g of protein supplies 600 calories, plus perhaps 20–30 g of fat for essential functions and fat-soluble nutrient absorption. Whole foods are preferred over protein powders, although obtaining very lean protein from food alone can be difficult.
  • Lean protein can be exceptionally filling: a large portion of shrimp without butter supplies relatively few calories, and some clients cannot finish their allotted protein. This approach is for people with excess body fat or a plateau, not lean people without a need for weight loss.
  • Dave found the opposite extreme, Amber O'Hearn's Keto AF approach of about two grams of fat per gram of protein, very satiating but accompanied by lethargy and concern about inadequate protein. Satiety and adequate lean-tissue nutrition are separate concerns.
  • Terms such as high-fat and high-protein need gram-based context. The Emmerichs' ordinary weight-loss eating might contain roughly 100-plus grams each of protein and fat, not an inherently low-fat diet; maintenance generally allows more fat. Ted Naiman's P:E Diet is another protein-versus-energy approach in the conversation. [5]

Insulin Resistance and Personal Fat Threshold

  • Dave can tolerate more carbohydrate while traveling in Europe because he walks and climbs stairs much more; Craig experienced similar activity in Japan. Dietary carbohydrate tolerance depends partly on energy use, muscle, and existing glucose control.
  • Two kinds of available fuel storage are central to Craig's current model: muscle for glucose and adipose tissue for fat. Building muscle and reducing body fat both create room to handle incoming energy.
  • Fat-cell number and capacity vary with genetics and development. Hyperplasia creates new adipocytes, whereas hypertrophy enlarges existing ones; most adults add relatively few new fat cells, although some people continue making them.
  • Once a person's adipocytes become overfilled, they resist further storage. Fat accumulates in blood triglycerides and ectopic locations such as liver and pancreas, contributing to the personal fat threshold, insulin resistance, and metabolic syndrome. This can occur at comparatively low body weight.
  • Dave likened the liver to a conductor receiving signals from multiple tissues. When heterogeneous adipocytes become enlarged and dysfunctional, signaling and immune activity deteriorate; biopsies of advanced fat tissue have found extensive macrophage infiltration.
  • A modest amount of weight loss, sometimes around 10%, can move someone below their personal fat threshold and restore useful storage capacity. It does not automatically undo longstanding pancreatic beta-cell failure or every other metabolic problem.
  • One client weighed about 105 lb but had severe diabetes, progressing from type 2 to insulin dependence that Craig called type 1, because she had little visible fat yet had lost effective fuel-storage capacity. Small size did not mean metabolic health.
  • The pancreas closely controls circulating glucose, whereas triglycerides can remain elevated for hours after a fatty meal. Dave's self-testing found triglycerides near 200 after a late fatty meal and below 100 the following fasted morning; blood-sampling time matters.
  • Lipodystrophy is an extreme example of inadequate adipose storage: little visible fat, high triglycerides, fatty liver, and sometimes xanthomas, with exogenous leptin potentially useful. Fat cells also communicate through hormones such as leptin and adiponectin.
  • Craig linked overfilled adipose tissue, excess circulating fuel, and elevated basal insulin. Dave challenged the idea that triglycerides alone directly raise insulin independently of glucose, which receives a much tighter insulin-mediated response. Glucose and triglycerides often rise together in metabolic dysfunction, while the precise causal mechanism remained contested.
  • A carnivore client with limited weight-gain tolerance gained a little weight while eating very high fat; triglycerides reached roughly the 400s and glucose around 150, then both improved when dietary fat fell. Carnivore alone does not guarantee favorable metabolic markers.

Carnivore as an Elimination Protocol, Not an Identity

  • Dave uses short, tightly defined beef-and-salt trials with baseline and follow-up bloodwork to identify dietary triggers. Soy marinades or beer can make a supposedly strict carnivore diet an uncontrolled elimination test.
  • The Emmerichs' Carnivore Cookbook [6] organizes the Carnivore Autoimmune Protocol by purpose: begin with beef and salt, add other animal proteins, then test eggs and dairy separately for about a week each, and finally add spices or limited plant foods as tolerated.
  • Weight loss and an autoimmune, skin, or neurological condition are different reasons for carnivore. An intensive elimination stage can help identify tolerated foods without requiring lifelong beef-and-salt restriction.
  • Long-term adherence is more important than the strictest dietary identity. Individuals may use strict carnivore, carnivore-adjacent, ketogenic, or broader low-carb eating based on metabolic health, symptoms, activity, and their ability to maintain the diet.
  • Craig ate only beef and salt for roughly six months yet continued to have serious Lyme-related illness. Failure cannot automatically mean inadequate carnivore strictness; some conditions require interventions outside diet.
  • Dave finds whole steak, beef patties, and eggs difficult to overeat, while refined foods, heavy cream, cheese, nuts, and fat bombs allow easier excess intake. Craig also cited unnamed satiety studies in which dairy and nuts were less filling than other foods for a given amount.
  • Diet names alone do not determine outcomes. Some high-carbohydrate fruitarians and carefully supplemented vegans achieve favorable weight and laboratory results; adequate protein, B12, vitamin D, and longer-term nutritional completeness still matter.

Why Elevated Insulin Accompanies Fat Gain

  • Craig questioned a simple carbohydrate-insulin explanation: if high fasting insulin prevents fat loss, why does initial fat loss often occur when fasting insulin is highest, with insulin falling as fat mass falls? This was an association, not proof of which event causes the other.
  • Dave's explanation was that insulin remains elevated longer when tissues fail to clear incoming fuel; after fat loss creates storage capacity, insulin clears fuel more successfully and falls. Sustained insulin exposure can therefore follow poor fuel disposal, beyond being an original cause.
  • Low-carbohydrate type 1 diabetes management furnished Craig's illustration: roughly 75% of daily insulin may be basal and 25% meal-related. Fasting insulin therefore contributes substantially to overall exposure beyond post-meal spikes.
  • Dave applied the traffic-jam analogy to lipoproteins: high triglyceride-rich VLDL can indicate slow turnover, while lean mass hyper-responders can have high LDL with rapid VLDL use and low circulating triglycerides.

A 575-Pound Client with Favorable Metabolic Labs

  • Tyler, a former schoolmate of Maria's, began working with the couple at about 645 lb. After losing weight to about 575 lb, Craig paid for bloodwork in anticipation of impaired glucose and insulin markers.
  • Tyler's fasting glucose on that test was about 60 mg/dL, though typically near 90; fasting insulin was around 2–3 (Craig first recalled 1.8, then 2.8), HOMA-IR about 0.4, and triglycerides in the 80s. These fasting markers were metabolically favorable despite his high weight.
  • Craig's explanation is that Tyler can still generate additional fat cells and thereby preserve adipose storage capacity without overfilling existing cells. He still has major mechanical and organ burdens from his weight; favorable blood markers do not mean extreme obesity is harmless.

Oxidative Priority and Protein Metabolism

  • Fuel oxidation follows urgency and storage capacity: alcohol first because it cannot be stored and is toxic, then carbohydrate because glycogen stores hold only a few thousand calories, and fat last because adipose capacity is much larger. Incoming energy not immediately burned is stored.
  • Protein serves chiefly as a source of structural and functional amino acids, not an ordinary fuel. Gluconeogenesis supplies glucose when needed, including for red blood cells, and is largely demand-driven rather than automatically converting every extra gram of meat into sugar.
  • Protein also requires substantial energy for digestion and processing, with thermic costs reaching about 35%. At extraordinary intakes such as 400–600 g of protein from shakes, excess amino acids may increase glucose production, but whole-food satiety makes such amounts difficult to reach.
  • Food structure matters alongside macronutrient totals. A rapidly consumed, refined 1,000-calorie milkshake can flood circulation with sugar and permit hunger to return soon afterward; a similar calorie load of whole eggs takes more effort to eat and can sustain fullness much longer.

Food Enjoyment, Dietary Revision, and Chronic Illness

  • Recipes make long-term low-carb eating practical for people who want sweets or familiar foods. Maria blended hard-boiled eggs with cocoa and sweetener into pudding for their son, and later made unusual high-protein foods such as chicken-based ice cream.
  • The couple changed their views about very high-fat keto, soy, and flax as their experience and reading evolved. They limit large quantities of seed oils, especially in processed sauces, but do not worry about every gram of omega-6 in chicken; linoleic acid is essential and dose matters.
  • They are also wary of high-dose omega-3 supplements because oils can oxidize during storage or use. Their preference is to reduce excess omega-6 intake and obtain omega-3s from ordinary foods such as fish, beef, and eggs.
  • The worst years of Craig's illness involved searching for possible answers at enormous personal cost, perhaps a quarter-million dollars over a decade. Pain relief after hip surgery allowed him to stop long-term painkillers; finding the specific causes of suffering mattered more than dietary ideology.
  • AI could help screen many more candidate therapies and match interventions more closely to individual genetics, though its trajectory remains uncertain. Dave also outlined plans for the Triad Study, a follow-up to his lean mass hyper-responder research, and a book about responsibility and slow change in institutional healthcare.

References

  1. [00:23] The Art of Metabolic Health — https://keto-adapted.com/product/the-art-of-metabolic-health/
  2. [00:26] The Ketogenic Cookbook — https://www.victorybelt.com/the-ketogenic-cookbook
  3. [00:33] Carbohydrate Restriction-Induced Elevations in LDL-Cholesterol and Atherosclerosis: The KETO Trial — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacadv.2024.101109
  4. [00:33] The Cholesterol Code (documentary) — https://cholesterolcodemovie.com/the-film/
  5. [01:17] The P:E Diet — https://thepediet.com/index.html
  6. [01:46] The Carnivore Cookbook — https://www.victorybelt.com/the-carnivore-cookbook

no comments (yet)

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
there doesn't seem to be anything here