Ah, so that's the context on that video. I ignored it due to the clickbait title and thumbnail. I've been ignoring a lot of his videos lately.
post
The irony of reporting on this from the largest consumer spying platform in existence, while collecting money from it...
This is not "participating in society", this is participating in, contributing to, and directly benefitting from the very thing they're complaining about.
contributing to, and directly benefitting from the very thing they’re complaining about.
You do understand what "participation" means, right? You understand that the original comic is specifically talking about contributing to and benefitting from the very thing they're complaining about, right?
I agree with your other point that GN should offer more alternatives to watch their videos, but this one is creating a distinction without a difference.
The original comic is referring to cars and iPhones (or smartphones more broadly). Basically, things you absolutely need to "participate in society" for most people. YouTube is very much not one of those things.
So you've moved the goalposts from "that's not just participation, it's [things that participation entails]" to "well this doesn't apply unless you need it to exist"*. GN needs a major platform like YouTube to actually reach an audience.
* By the way, the comic is illustrating a man with a car that's seemingly from the 1920s or 30s, so there goes that tenuous argument.
I know plenty of people without cars or smartphones that still participate in society. This is a terrible argument.
TheTechnician27 has volunteered to improve our lives. When’s the peertube instance comrade?
It's where eyeballs live, otherwise you only reach small amount of tech nerds.
That's why you make it available elsewhere for "tech nerds" who don't want to be a part of the problem.
I wouldn't mind if they also mirrored their videos on Nebula.
You would if you looked at Nebula's privacy policy.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I don't see really anything of concerns that stands out
Did you even look?
Nebula, our service providers, and our advertising partners may automatically log information about you, your computer, or mobile device, and your activity over time on our Services and other sites and online services.
Online activity information, such as information about your use of and actions on the Services, such as the website you visited before browsing to our Services, pages or screens you viewed, how long you spent on a page or screen, navigation paths between pages or screens, information about your activity on a page or screen, access times, and duration of access.
Interest-Based Advertising. We may work with third-party advertising companies and social media companies to help us advertise our business
Advertising Partners. We may also share personal information with third parties who we partner with for advertising campaigns or that collect information about your activity on the Services for the purposes described in the "Interest-Based Advertising" section above.
Analytics. The Nebula Store uses Google Analytics to help us analyze how the Website is being accessed and used.
Do Not Track. Some browsers may be configured to send "Do Not Track" signals to online services that you visit. The Website does not respond to "Do Not Track" or similar signals.
Fully agreed. At least give an alternative source. But that would not play well with the goal of any of these YT "influencer" videos - cashing in.
Walk the walk.
all 25 comments