As moderator of !biscuits@feddit.uk i can confirm I eat all cookies

It would depend on the flavour. Actually, who am I kidding, if someone bakes me a cookie of me, I'm going full cookie monster on it, pretty much regardless of flavour or decoration.

Depends if I like whomever made it.. if a friend made it for me I’d get the go-ahead to set it in resin to keep it and ask them for another cookie of regular decoration, cuz that would take a lot of effort and stuff.

If it was made by some rando or a genie or something, meh cookie is cookie even if it is ugly.