I believe the big problem is that neither proof might be really satisfying to mathematicians. The Riemann Hypothesis is a relatively easy to understand, simple problem, and the massive amounts of math required to bring it to heel at this point - whether by AI or human - makes one wonder if a better, simpler, more intuitive approach is possible.
This is a little like the way the ancient Greeks started calculating pi by ever-increasing polygons fitted around the circle. Start with a hexagon, double that to 12 sides, then 24, then 48. Calculate pi based on an inscribed and a bounding polygon. So much work.
Then Euler shows up and declares that you can get the same number, pi, from a simple infinite, converging sum. A simple ratio (pi being the ratio between perimeter and diameter of a circle) turned out not to require complicated geometrical computations, after all.
In many ways, it would have been much cooler if AI had found a counterexample and the RH had collapsed.