I think the newest logo goes too far, away from easily recognizeable.
The 'modern' I could see the argument for, stripping out the details but here's a whale with containers on it. Two details, containers that represent what the software is about, and a whale for fun. Now remove the containers and you are left with the whale with zero tie into what they are about.
But maybe that's just it, they are a bit adrift as they don't have much of a viable business plan, since their would-be path up the stack got cut off by Kubernetes and they are relegated to companies that just mindlessly think it makes sense to pay subscriptions for something like docker desktop.