you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 4 points 15 hours ago (4 children)

Assuming it was posted in good faith, this woman's post was probably not meant to be a condemnation of Indonesian culture.

It sounds to me that this woman is probably just happy to share progressive ideas that she inherited from her cultural background and sees as good with kids who maybe aren't exposed to those particular aspects. I think any man or woman who marries into another culture takes a little pleasure in bringing their own flavor into their new family just as much as they enjoy taking in those new flavors. Especially when the thing that they're introducing is something like, I don't know, feminism.

Cultural exchange goes both ways. It would be absurd for her to post this one happy and slightly strange aspect of her life and then post a paragraph or two explaining how it doesn't reflect any pro-colonial or racist ideas. It would be strange to coach your post on social media like that. I don't know why you would expect that.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] -1 points 14 hours ago (3 children)

    You offer such an extraordinary amount of charitable good faith to OP that it verges on gaslighting.

    But I will extend extra good faith of my own by pointing out you are defending the woman’s good intentions while I’m pointing out that—regardless of her intentions—her post is troublesome all the same.

    She might be genuinely well-intentioned, sincerely feminist, and interested in helping children think critically. Fine.

    None of that establishes that her framing is free of Eurocentric assumptions. You don't have to consciously endorse racial or cultural hierarchies to reproduce them.

    You’ve also inadvertently reinforced my central argument: you describe feminism as progressive ideas the woman "inherited from her cultural background."

    But feminism isn't uniquely Swedish or European. And actually, Indonesia has its own substantial feminist history.

    Treating progressive values as something Europeans bring to non-European societies Is white supremacist as hell.

    And your appeal to cultural exchange doesn’t address the asymmetry. Sure, cultural exchange goes both ways. That’s true, but OP isn’t describing a reciprocal exchange.

    Instead, she’s celebrating her status as a Swedish woman introducing her progressive worldview to an Indonesian family. Nothing in the post suggests she's similarly interested in questioning her own cultural assumptions.

    Finally, you’re attacking an expectation I didn’t express. Nobody demanded that the woman write paragraphs disavowing colonialism or racism.

    My criticism is about what she chose to emphasize, specifically her Swedish identity and supposedly progressive values against her husband's Indonesian family.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    Couldn't we reasonably assume that her post only makes sense if the husbands family does not subscribe to a feminist viewpoint, Indonesian or not?

    Feminism is not exclusive to Sweden, but the entire premise of the post only really makes sense if this woman took secular and feminist ideas she inherited from her background in Sweden into an Indonesian family who hasn't been exposed to much secularism and feminism, and the poster thought it was funny. Idk, i can't read their mind, but that's how the short hand reads to me.

    It's clumsy, sure. Maybe the optics are worse than I thought. I've personally felt similar to OP when spending time in a conservative Christian church group in the south united States. It was fun to feel like a spy trying to seed socially progressive ideas into an ideological galvanized group of friendly people who I liked.

    I don't know enough about Indonesian stereotypes to say whether this joke makes sense. But, if the joke had been A swedish woman in an American family, it'd have landed the same for me, since the joke only makes sense if the American family is fundamentalist Christian, which is a common enough stereotype of Americans.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

    If her husband’s family is patriarchical and religious, then that’s simply the case regardless of whether or not they are Indonesian.

    But if that’s the case regardless, then why did OP mention their ethnicity? And why did she mention her own?

    We all need to remember that Indonesia was colonized by Europeans for 350 years. That colonization included theft of land, slavery, and mass killings.

    Much of this was buried until 2022 when, after an investigation, the Netherlands finally apologized.

    So I don’t think this is quite the same as you hanging around an American church group unless that church group was composed of Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous peoples.

    More to the point, Europeans shouldn’t be implying their culture is more “progressive” than others when Europeans spent hundreds of years oppressing others in the pursuit of extractive wealth.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 12 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago)

    If her husband’s family is patriarchical and religious, then that’s simply the case regardless of whether or not they are Indonesian.

    Not necessarily. Many cultures have unique religious pressures that enforce or embed patriarchy in particularly pernicious ways.

    This is what i mean by I don't know about the stereotypes. I'm curious, so I'll google it. I honestly don't know much about Indonesia or Sweden.

    Wikipedia says Indonesia is predominately Islamic. 88%, with the rest largely flavors of Christian. A common hallmark of Abrahamic religions is regimented patriarchy. Religion and patriarchy are the only specific aspects in the original meme, and it's logical to assume that those characteristics are what led OP to repost it.

    To be fair, Sweden is not free of Abrahmic religion. Wikipedia says Sweden is predominantly Christian with a large minority of "no religion", 39%. It is possible that OP is Christian. However, since the image specially characterises the poster as challenging religion, OP likely resides in that large minority, and her Indonesian relatives in a very large majority.

    But if that’s the case regardless, then why did OP mention their ethnicity? And why did she mention her own?

    Because to OP this is likely what she sees. Probably, Her new Indonesian family is made up of socially conservative Muslims and her own family background is probably socially liberal agnostics. To her it is a convenient shorthand.

    Unless there is some incidious racist dogwhistle I'm missing in OP's post, it seems like a pretty straightforward personal experience. The optics of a European wife positioning herself as making the kids woke might be bad, but it could be as simple as that's exactly what's happening. And if that's exactly what's happening, then whatever. Better that more kids think critically of religion and patriarchy, if it comes from a weird Swedish aunt or not.

    I guess what got me annoyed in the first place is if is just bad optics, and this really is a woman posting about deprogramming her neices or whatever, then being dogpiled about colonialism would be a really lame lemmy experience. Maybe it is a dogwhistle and there is no Swedish wife and no Indonesian family. But, I don't see anyone saying that?

    Edit: after posting this, i did get a sinking feeling and checked OPs comment history. She doesn't seem like a troll. Commented in a thread about her husband. Posted a few feminist memes. Nothing Indonesian mentioned. So, there is no obvious trolling skimming the account. And the Swedish / Indonesian thing just reads to me as too specific and random to be a dogwhistle.

  • source
  • parent