you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] -5 points 19 hours ago* (last edited 18 hours ago) (16 children)

It’s one thing to challenge religion and conservative beliefs.

It’s quite another thing to frame herself as an enlightened outsider bringing progressive values to a supposedly backward family.

Especially when this post makes it a point to trumpet her as young, Swedish, and progressive, in contrast to her husband's Indonesian family—which is supposedly not.

It’s further suspicious when she treats children as instruments of ideological conflict. If it’s merely a matter of teaching young people to think critically—okay. But if this is just an exercise in trying to get children to adopt her particular conclusions, she’s teaching them nothing except another prescriptive moral stance.

She also prides herself on making others question their assumptions. But how willing is she to question her own? If she’s just administering criticism without doing her own self-examination, then I question whether she’s applying this principle universally.

Finally, posting this on social media is quite performative. The post is structured around the satisfaction she derives from being a disruptive presence at family gatherings. The children, religion, and patriarchy are supporting characters in a story about her own self-image.

For this reason, I don’t think she’s quite deserving of a high-five.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 16 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 15 hours ago (4 children)

    Assuming it was posted in good faith, this woman's post was probably not meant to be a condemnation of Indonesian culture.

    It sounds to me that this woman is probably just happy to share progressive ideas that she inherited from her cultural background and sees as good with kids who maybe aren't exposed to those particular aspects. I think any man or woman who marries into another culture takes a little pleasure in bringing their own flavor into their new family just as much as they enjoy taking in those new flavors. Especially when the thing that they're introducing is something like, I don't know, feminism.

    Cultural exchange goes both ways. It would be absurd for her to post this one happy and slightly strange aspect of her life and then post a paragraph or two explaining how it doesn't reflect any pro-colonial or racist ideas. It would be strange to coach your post on social media like that. I don't know why you would expect that.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] -1 points 14 hours ago (3 children)

    You offer such an extraordinary amount of charitable good faith to OP that it verges on gaslighting.

    But I will extend extra good faith of my own by pointing out you are defending the woman’s good intentions while I’m pointing out that—regardless of her intentions—her post is troublesome all the same.

    She might be genuinely well-intentioned, sincerely feminist, and interested in helping children think critically. Fine.

    None of that establishes that her framing is free of Eurocentric assumptions. You don't have to consciously endorse racial or cultural hierarchies to reproduce them.

    You’ve also inadvertently reinforced my central argument: you describe feminism as progressive ideas the woman "inherited from her cultural background."

    But feminism isn't uniquely Swedish or European. And actually, Indonesia has its own substantial feminist history.

    Treating progressive values as something Europeans bring to non-European societies Is white supremacist as hell.

    And your appeal to cultural exchange doesn’t address the asymmetry. Sure, cultural exchange goes both ways. That’s true, but OP isn’t describing a reciprocal exchange.

    Instead, she’s celebrating her status as a Swedish woman introducing her progressive worldview to an Indonesian family. Nothing in the post suggests she's similarly interested in questioning her own cultural assumptions.

    Finally, you’re attacking an expectation I didn’t express. Nobody demanded that the woman write paragraphs disavowing colonialism or racism.

    My criticism is about what she chose to emphasize, specifically her Swedish identity and supposedly progressive values against her husband's Indonesian family.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    Couldn't we reasonably assume that her post only makes sense if the husbands family does not subscribe to a feminist viewpoint, Indonesian or not?

    Feminism is not exclusive to Sweden, but the entire premise of the post only really makes sense if this woman took secular and feminist ideas she inherited from her background in Sweden into an Indonesian family who hasn't been exposed to much secularism and feminism, and the poster thought it was funny. Idk, i can't read their mind, but that's how the short hand reads to me.

    It's clumsy, sure. Maybe the optics are worse than I thought. I've personally felt similar to OP when spending time in a conservative Christian church group in the south united States. It was fun to feel like a spy trying to seed socially progressive ideas into an ideological galvanized group of friendly people who I liked.

    I don't know enough about Indonesian stereotypes to say whether this joke makes sense. But, if the joke had been A swedish woman in an American family, it'd have landed the same for me, since the joke only makes sense if the American family is fundamentalist Christian, which is a common enough stereotype of Americans.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

    If her husband’s family is patriarchical and religious, then that’s simply the case regardless of whether or not they are Indonesian.

    But if that’s the case regardless, then why did OP mention their ethnicity? And why did she mention her own?

    We all need to remember that Indonesia was colonized by Europeans for 350 years. That colonization included theft of land, slavery, and mass killings.

    Much of this was buried until 2022 when, after an investigation, the Netherlands finally apologized.

    So I don’t think this is quite the same as you hanging around an American church group unless that church group was composed of Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous peoples.

    More to the point, Europeans shouldn’t be implying their culture is more “progressive” than others when Europeans spent hundreds of years oppressing others in the pursuit of extractive wealth.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 12 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago)

    If her husband’s family is patriarchical and religious, then that’s simply the case regardless of whether or not they are Indonesian.

    Not necessarily. Many cultures have unique religious pressures that enforce or embed patriarchy in particularly pernicious ways.

    This is what i mean by I don't know about the stereotypes. I'm curious, so I'll google it. I honestly don't know much about Indonesia or Sweden.

    Wikipedia says Indonesia is predominately Islamic. 88%, with the rest largely flavors of Christian. A common hallmark of Abrahamic religions is regimented patriarchy. Religion and patriarchy are the only specific aspects in the original meme, and it's logical to assume that those characteristics are what led OP to repost it.

    To be fair, Sweden is not free of Abrahmic religion. Wikipedia says Sweden is predominantly Christian with a large minority of "no religion", 39%. It is possible that OP is Christian. However, since the image specially characterises the poster as challenging religion, OP likely resides in that large minority, and her Indonesian relatives in a very large majority.

    But if that’s the case regardless, then why did OP mention their ethnicity? And why did she mention her own?

    Because to OP this is likely what she sees. Probably, Her new Indonesian family is made up of socially conservative Muslims and her own family background is probably socially liberal agnostics. To her it is a convenient shorthand.

    Unless there is some incidious racist dogwhistle I'm missing in OP's post, it seems like a pretty straightforward personal experience. The optics of a European wife positioning herself as making the kids woke might be bad, but it could be as simple as that's exactly what's happening. And if that's exactly what's happening, then whatever. Better that more kids think critically of religion and patriarchy, if it comes from a weird Swedish aunt or not.

    I guess what got me annoyed in the first place is if is just bad optics, and this really is a woman posting about deprogramming her neices or whatever, then being dogpiled about colonialism would be a really lame lemmy experience. Maybe it is a dogwhistle and there is no Swedish wife and no Indonesian family. But, I don't see anyone saying that?

    Edit: after posting this, i did get a sinking feeling and checked OPs comment history. She doesn't seem like a troll. Commented in a thread about her husband. Posted a few feminist memes. Nothing Indonesian mentioned. So, there is no obvious trolling skimming the account. And the Swedish / Indonesian thing just reads to me as too specific and random to be a dogwhistle.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 4 points 17 hours ago (10 children)

    Boy that's a lot of wild assumptions...

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] -1 points 17 hours ago (9 children)

    Did OP not make it a point to focus on her specific identity as a white, young Swedish woman in contra to her husband’s family?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 9 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 17 hours ago* (8 children)

    Yes I'm referring to the "everything else", not the single indisputable bit of context we have.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 16 hours ago (7 children)

    What exactly do you mean by “everything else”? You're making a vague accusation without identifying a single specific argument you disagree with.

    My central criticism is that OP frames herself as a young, enlightened, progressive Swedish woman in contrast to her Indonesian husband's family. That framing reproduces a familiar Eurocentric narrative in which Europeans bring enlightenment to supposedly backward non-Europeans.

    You can challenge religious conservatism without reproducing that kind of cultural hierarchy.

    If you think my interpretation is wrong, explain why. Simply calling everything you disagree with a “wild assumption” isn't an argument.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 15 hours ago* (last edited 15 hours ago) (6 children)

    Good lord you really are serious about this. Okay the biggest glaring issue I see is you assuming the meme and the title refer to the same person. Like that's sorta a doozy.

    Also you assume that she treats children as "instruments of ideological conflict" which is a real leap. (Also yknow, totally removes agency from children. But thats a side issue)

    Also "prides herself on making others question their choices" which was never said anywhere

    You also assume this is disruptive, that the family isn't european, that there are no conditions where europeans can bring new ideas to another culture without it being imperialism, you strongly imply in a big just asking questions way that she wouldn't be willing to question her own beliefs, you cast this as being unwelcome, etc...

    (edit: oops, fatfingered send early)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] -1 points 14 hours ago (5 children)

    It is true that the the title and embedded tweet may refer to two different people, but I can safely assume that, based on the post title, OP is who she says she is and the tweet aligns with her experience.

    OP deliberately paired the image with a post title about being Swedish, progressive, and married into an Indonesian family.

    It is likewise true that children have some degree of agency. Not as much as adults do, but some nonetheless. And it might be true OP is just teaching children the skills of critical thinking—I’ve already allowed that this might be the case.

    But since she’s framed herself as young, progressive, and Swedish, I am equally right to be skeptical about her ability to question her own biases.

    OP decided to point out her husband’s family is Indonesian. She didn’t have to have to do this.

    Finally, when did I say that Europeans cannot introduce ideas into other cultures without committing imperialism? That is a textbook strawman when my objection isn’t to OP’s ideas but to the Eurocentrism.

    She explicitly contrasted her Swedish progressive identity with her husband's Indonesian family, framing European culture as enlightened and non-European culture as backward and in need of correction.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 14 hours ago* (4 children)

    I am equally right to be skeptical about her ability to question her own biases

    Mmmmmmk, why?

    It is likewise true that children have some degree of agency. Not as much as adults do, but some nonetheless.

    Okay, creepy take.

    I’ve already allowed that this might be the case.

    All of your criticism hinges on the assumption it isn't.

    imperialism

    Ah apologies, typo. You can safely replace the term with "eurocentrism" and my criticism stands on that.

    She explicitly contrasted her Swedish progressive identity with her husband’s Indonesian family, framing European culture as enlightened and non-European culture as backward and in need of correction.

    Ah, explicitly? Perhaps there was some other followup post where she did that you provide me with? As it stands now, the poster presents pride in introducing new concepts to people who may not have been exposed to them before. That's nothing to do with correction - and tediously you're now denying agency to the entire family in this case.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 13 hours ago (3 children)

    Yes, explicitly:

    I love being the young, Swedish, progressive wife in my husband's Indonesian family.

    Those are her words.

    I didn’t invent the nationalities, the association between her Swedish identity and her progressivism, and how it’s contrasted with her husband’s Indonesian family.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 13 hours ago* (2 children)

    Yes it is what she said, but I'll wait until you get around to editing in responses to all the other points before I bother explaining how that has nothing to do with your assumption to you :)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 13 hours ago (1 child)

    No, I’m not going to waste my time discussing canards when my concern was what was explicitly stated in the title of the post.

    She chose the wording. I quoted her. We’ve established that OP explicitly juxtaposes her Swedish progressive identity in contra to her Indonesian family.

    So I think we’re done here.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 13 hours ago*

    Mmmm, no your concern was that I pointed out how many unjustified assumptions you were using to justify a strawman of OP you could rail against. You asked, I answered, you refused to engage in any substantive way - but hey I'll go easy on you, you can just explain this one:

    I am equally right to be skeptical about her ability to question her own biases

    Looking forward to it!

  • source
  • parent