The 11s are basically free, and the MSRP should be ignored.
I just ordered a 11 pro phone (with 16gb ram) and a 5 LTE watch. For both the only thing I'm paying for is the sales tax. I'm locked into Google Fi for 2 years, but it's like $40/month all in for unlimited plus they now use Verizon and Tmobile.
My old ass phone is fine, but the plan is cheaper than what I was playing, so for me the choice to upgrade is a no brainer since I was already going back to Fi.
That being said...
If someone has a decent phone and is going to actually pay for an 11, they're almost certainly better off with a different phone or waiting a year for the 12 if they want a Pixel.
We're well past annual or biannual upgrades being necessary. People can (and should) be going 4-5 years between phones.