I (a different guy, in case you skip unames like I do) agree, but frankly I think it's time for the melting pot to finally melt together and come to define an American culture (likely based off of all the others), (and also we kind of already have it we just need to consciously define and shape it into what we want). FUCK "I'm Italian," "I'm Anglo," if you're >x generations removed it's time to become American. Not from a nationalist standpoint really, just "we've been around long enough, it's time."
We just need to make that something people want to claim... which is the hard part. In some ways we have, the American South is a really good example of it specifically through the food (which btw is multiracial fuck off on the "south mentioned must be racism" bullshit), all the food is based off of other cultures but tweaked through the years into something distinct and unique, and delicious. Mostly due to necessity, but still, a lot of innovation was born from necessity.
And to some degree, we're big, we might not ever have an "American culture" just as there really isn't a cohesive "European culture," the Dutch are different than the Italians, hell Sicilian Italians are different than Italians, but we could have like, Southeast, Southwest, Northwest, Midwest, and Northeast, (and we kind of already do if we want to just acknowledge that and accept that our previous roots did in fact influence the development of those because that's how it fucking works lol).