I could forgive the excesses of the AI industry if they had made a durable artifact which would provide real value to everyone continuously forever, and thereafter simply stopped the excesses. If they could but say "this is it, this is our model, the one we're going with, we aren't going to train a new one, what this one does is what it does, take it or leave it", then I would evaluate what the model did and did not do, and weigh its value against what was put into it, and project it to the future. The problem is that the value it produces is very, very low. If it actually did the things they claim it did, it would be worth having a current frontier model hang around even with bad origins. But it doesn't do those things. It tries to, certainly, but it fails. It falls flat at coding large projects beyond its context window, it cannot be a reliable reference guide to any topic, it can't reliably describe images better than guessing, it can't make decent art or music or poetry or prose. The very limited real value it does produce for tiny codebases isn't worth the value of the resources put into it, when those tiny codebases can just as easily be written by hand and understood by a human.And then there's the human factor: even if it delivered on all its promises, it's moot because nobody wants what it produces, making the value of the output effectively zero even projected to an infinite future.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 1 point 18 hours ago

What it amounts to is a very neat technical trick, in the sense of a dog walking on its hind legs while barking 'Puttin' on the Ritz'. It's neat. It's not something you see every day. But it's also no basis for an industry, let alone an economy.

  • source