you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 81 points 3 days ago (14 children)

Fun fact: It is impossible to solve unemployment under Capitalism. The moment demand for labour exceeds supply, wages start increasing until profits are gone. There has to be an unemployed, desperate class for wages to stay under control and businesses profitable.

  • source
  • hideshow 14 child comments
  • [–] 17 points 3 days ago*

    Some related theory if anyone's interested, written in the 1920s:

    'How does capitalism keep the unemployed on hand?’ you ask.

    Simply by compelling you to work long hours and as hard as possible, so as to produce the greatest amount. All the modern schemes of ‘efficiency’, the Taylor and other systems of ‘economy’ and ‘rationalization’ serve only to squeeze greater profits out of the worker. It is economy in the interest of the employer only. But as concerns you, the worker, this ‘economy’ spells the greatest expenditure of your effort and energy, a fatal waste of your vitality.

    It pays the employer to use up and exploit your strength and ability at the highest tension. True, it ruins your health and breaks down your nervous system, makes you a prey to illness and disease (there are even special proletarian diseases), cripples you and brings you to an early grave — but what does your boss care? Are there not thousands of unemployed waiting for your job and ready to take it the moment you are disabled or dead?

    That is why it is to the profit of the capitalist to keep an army of unemployed ready at hand. It is part and parcel of the wage system, a necessary and inevitable characteristic of it.

    It is in the interest of the people that there should be no unemployed, that all should have an opportunity to work and earn their living; that all should help, each according to his ability and strength, to increase the wealth of the country, so that each should be able to have a greater share of it.

    But capitalism is not interested in the welfare of the people. Capitalism, as I have shown before, is interested only in profits. By employing less people and working them long hours larger profits can be made than by giving work to more people at shorter hours. That is why it is to the interest of your employer, for instance, to have 100 people work 10 hours daily rather than to employ 200 at 5 hours. He would need more room for 200 than for 100 persons — a larger factory, more tools and machinery, and so on. That is, he would require a greater investment of capital. The employment of a larger force at less hours would bring less profits, and that is why your boss will not run his factory or shop on such a plan. Which means that a system of profit-making is not compatible with considerations of humanity and the well-being of the workers. On the contrary, the harder and more ‘efficiently’ you work and the longer hours you stay at it, the better for your employer and the greater his profits.

    You can therefore see that capitalism is not interested in employing all those who want and are able to work. On the contrary: a minimum of ‘hands’ and a maximum of effort is the principle and the profit of the capitalist system. This is the whole secret of all ‘rationalization’ schemes. And that is why you will find thousands of people in every capitalist country willing and anxious to work, yet unable to get employment. This army of unemployed is a constant threat to your standard of living. They are ready to take your place at lower pay, because necessity compels them to it. That is, of course, very advantageous to the boss: it is a whip in his hands constantly held over you, so you will slave hard for him and ‘behave’ yourself.

    You can see for yourself how dangerous and degrading such a situation is for the worker, not to speak of the other evils of the system.

    ‘Then why not do away with unemployment?’ you demand.

    Yes, it would be fine to do away with it. But it could be accomplished only by doing away with the capitalist system and its wage slavery. As long as you have capitalism — or any other system of labor exploitation and profit-making — you will have unemployment. Capitalism can’t exist without it: it is inherent in the wage system. It is the fundamental condition of successful capitalist production.

    ‘Why?’

    Because the capitalist industrial system does not produce for the needs of the people; it produces for profit. Manufacturers do not produce commodities because the people want them and as much of them as is required. They produce what they expect to sell, and sell at a profit.

    If we had a sensible system, we would produce the things which the people want and the quantity they need. Suppose the inhabitants of a certain locality needed 1,000 pairs of shoes; and suppose we’d have 50 shoemakers for the job. Then in 20 hours work those shoemakers would produce the shoes our community needs.

    But the shoemaker of to-day does not know and does not care how many pairs of shoes are needed. Thousands of people may need new shoes in your city, but they cannot afford to buy them. So what good is it to the manufacturer to know who needs shoes? What he wants to know is who can buy the shoes he makes: how many pairs he can sell at a profit.

    What happens? Well, he will manufacture about as many pairs of shoes as he thinks he will be able to sell. He will try his best to produce them as cheaply and sell them as dearly as he can, so as to make a good profit. He will therefore employ as few workers as possible to manufacture the quantity of shoes he wants, and he will have them work as ‘efficiently’ and hard as he can compel them to.

    You see that production for profit means longer hours and fewer persons employed than would be the case if production were for use.

    Capitalism is the system of production for profit, and that is why capitalism always must have unemployed.

    But look further into this system of production for profit and you will see how its basic evil works a hundred other evils.

    Let us follow the shoe manufacturer of your city...

    From Now and After by Alexander Berkman. Chapter 5: Unemployment.

    Available to read or download in various formats, for free, here: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/alexander-berkman-what-is-communist-anarchism

  • source
  • parent
  • There is a path towards syndicalism. A progressive wealth cap. Which forces the assets transferred from private equities to co-op-like structures, forming employee/consumer-owned corporations. The beauty is that the wealth is still isolated from the state to avoid authoritarianism. Then, remove the remaining centralized power structure that reduces the risk of any power corruption.

    One can only dream

  • source
  • parent
  • [+] -16 points 3 days ago (10 children)

    Under unfettered capitalism. That’s why you mix in some socialism to fetter your capitalism, and get the best of both worlds. With a mix of capitalism and socialism, you can have the market efficiencies of capitalism, and a social safety net that insures nobody is destitute.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 14 points 3 days ago

    unfettered capitalism

    Capitalists don't like fetters. They are constantly trying to unfetter themselves.

    At some point, you're asking to live with a hippopotamus, but sternly insisting the hippo never get large enough to stomp on you.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 17 points 3 days ago (7 children)

    I love when y'all call it unfettered capitalism. Cuz you're just admitting right there in the name that this system is a rabid violent creature by nature that is designed to kill us. That is designed to savage the human race.

    The problem is fetters always break or come undone eventually. And then people have to die to put them back. Seems like a stupid system.

    And even that's assuming the fetters work and are on correctly which I absolutely do not do.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 3 days ago (6 children)

    Cuz you’re just admitting right there in the name that this system is a rabid violent creature by nature that is designed to kill us.

    I mean, the nature of fire is that it is both very useful and very dangerous.

    Even Marx conceded the incredible transformative potential of a capitalist economy. That's why he suggested the necessity of passing through a capitalist phase of development before proceeding to socialism and communism.

    When you look at the surviving socialist states - Cuba, Vietnam, North Korea, China, Venezuela, Bolivia, the Nordic Bloc - they've all implemented capitalist practices at some internal level.

    The more prosperous states have been the ones that wrangled capitalism successfully. Controlling and policing the capitalist class has been the big challenge. But just obliterating markets and trying to run the entire economy from a Central Community is herding cats. Exhausting and largely fruitless. People will form their own black markets whether you want them to or not. It's the natural response to regional resource and labor constraints.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 3 days ago (4 children)

    The Nordic bloc are surviving socialist states??

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 2 days ago (2 children)

    They are at least as socialist as Venezuela. They just get to implement a public system on the back of an enormous petrostate surplus because they sided with America in the Cold War. Same reason Canada gets to have a national health care system.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 2 days ago (1 child)

    But it's not like any of them were ever controlled by a socialist/communist party at any point, like China, Cuba, or Vietnam. They're just standard social democracy, not even dengism. Venezuela isn't socialist either afaik

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 2 days ago*

    But it’s not like any of them were ever controlled by a socialist/communist party at any point

    Socialist parties took control of the various Scandinavian governments back in the 1930s, about the same time they were popping up across the rest of Europe.

    The big difference between the Nordic states and the rest of Continental Europe was the lack of a sudden violent change of power. Consequently, there was no Losing Side from which the government could quickly and easily transfer wealth.

    Instead, the Nords created state agencies to develop publicly owned enterprises, which rapidly enriched themselves on petrochemical production, refining, and export.

    Public ownership of means of production is textbook socialism. But it is somewhat unique for a country to create the founding national entities as public and then grow them into global market players as state owned enterprises.

    China, Cuba, or Vietnam

    All had large agricultural economies that were expropriated by socialist governments after revolution.

    Swedes, Nords, and Fins built their public system from the ground up with public labor.

    It's akin to the university systems in the US, Europe, and East Asia, in that way. Enormous fountains of economic value produced almost entirely through public construction, investment, and employment.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 12 points 3 days ago

    That's not a mix of socialism and capitalism, that's welfare capitalism, with all the weaknesses I described to you before:

    Using the Nordics as an example, we can see that their safety nets are eroding, and that workers don't actually hold power, capitalists do. Moreover, they fund their safety nets from imperialism and unequal exchange, meaning it only temporarily "works" if you accept being a drain on humanity, needing entire other countries to support the existence of each "working" social democracy. Socialism, on the other hand, has been proven to work, and needs no such mechanisms of global plunder to support the safety nets they have.

  • source
  • parent