you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 7 points 1 day ago (2 children)

You're in an area where a binary gender model just breaks down. Whilst convenient for most people in most situations, this is like trying to use Newton's laws of motion to understand the event horizon of a black hole. You need a different model of the world.

The model I use is this: humans have many independent systems/traits within their brains and bodies, several of which are typically found in a bi-modal distribution of states which we label "male" and "female". In trans, non-binary, and intersex people the bi-modality of that distribution starts to break down. Some systems/traits are aligned with the "male" mode, others with the "female" mode. Not all are easy or even possible to change: some are baked into how the brain works.

In some of those people (trans men, trans women) it just happens that several less-visible systems/traits we cannot (or should not) change are aligned in the opposite direction to a bunch of more-visible systems/traits we can change, and that their lives become much more tolerable if they are allowed to make some changes. This usually happens via some combination of hormones & surgery, and really needs to depend on the individual because the systems/traits can be misaligned in a variety of ways and some of the treatments affect several systems in a way that cannot be quantified before treatment.

If the ultimate goal of a trans man / trans woman would be to transition to better fit the classical male/female mode they would prefer, then they probably want to be labelled and treated as their preferred gender with no additional qualifications at all, but some still want their journey to be recognised so sometimes you need to ask anyway.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 1 day ago (1 child)

    The model I use is this: humans have many independent systems/traits within their brains and bodies

    That largely falls in with gender constructivism & gender permittivity which are philosophies that make sense to me. My personal perspective is that people should aspire to exclude anything related to biology (chromosome & hormones included) because choosing to not do that bars many trans & cis people from ever "fully becoming" their chosen gender. If being a [Gender] means having some 100 traits, and some of those traits are defined by biology, then they might only be 95% [Gender]. And then it invites discussion of being a 'full man' and similar terms that lead to transphobic and other toxic ideologies.

    That said, I say aspire, because I think it's hard for most people to fully 100% separate them. Like the old 'everyone is a little bit racist, sometimes' joke/bit.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago

    I would say that cis people also have most but often not all traits aligned with their preferred mode there, resolving that from the other side. So they'd have to say that a woman with a little facial hair is not a woman, or that a man who prefers to avoid violence is not a man. Then they'd need to claim that maybe 60+% of all people are intersex, and "real" men/women are minorities.

  • source
  • parent