This is not correct. Yes, the ISPs might all use Openreach or Cityfibre as the physical connections but they still all run their own networks though these cables.
These networks will vary in reliability and network capacity. Cityfibre and Openreach provide the physical cables but they don’t provide the ISPs routers or set up their network for them.
Due to this saying two ISPs on the Cityfibre or Openreach will be just as reliable as one another is definitely not true.