you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 6 days ago

If you want to ban videos, ban the videos. Banning an entire platform is nonsense. All you’re doing is reinforcing YouTube’s monopoly.

Plenty of other platforms are not banned, so the monopoly part is nonsense.

And why not ban the individual videos?

  1. Because mods are human beings with limited resources. And if one platform spews out a much higher rate of garbage then the other, then banning the higher proportion one might just be a common sense choice to take the load of mods back. This is a volunteer run space, after all. And saying "no raw milk in our house because that gets you sick 20% of the time, but salad is allowed because that gets you sick 2% of the time" is a perfectly reasonable heuristic.
  2. Because there other ways of looking at it. If you for good reason think that the people who run platform X are shitback or are receiving most of their funding from problematic sources, have a moderation policy you don't agree with etc. etc. that might also be a reason to block it. You might not agree with that reasoning or think it is wrong, but it might still be perfectly defendable depending on what moral framework you have.
🏆 1
  • source
  • parent