Basically I'm like 99% sure I'm trans. If I could just magically physically be a woman right now, I would immediately, and probably never present male again.

However, I look male, I have a beard, broad shoulders, a penis, etc, and I don't really mind either. Transitioning would be annoying and since I lived so long as a man, I'll never pass, and I don't like a "mixed look" at all. And yeah, I really don't mind my body, I find men attractive, I find women attractive, I find myself attractive. I'm fine with what biology decided I should look like.

Does anyone share this kind of view on themselves? I only have tangential contact with any trans communities, and I never really see this sentiment represented.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 1 month ago

I’ve been out as trans for ten years, and even though I was on HRT for several years at the beginning, I’ve mostly given up on it. The only other medical thing I’ve done is laser hair removal, since body hair was a big source of dysphoria. I realized HRT wouldn’t change my body in the ways that I really wanted i.e. making my body smaller and skinnier. And I like my genitals and would never get bottom surgery. I’m a pretty big and masculine trans woman but I’ve kinda accepted that I just Look Like This, and there’s not much else for me to “do” about it.

The social transition was scary at first but it ended up being generally easy. My family and friends were accepting, and I’ve changed my legal name & gender marker on my license, etc. This is just me now, and it’s more comfortable.

That said, don’t need to do anything at all. Just chase your bliss. You don’t have to have dysphoria or alter your body in any way to be trans. This is a harmful notion that prevents a lot of people from taking a new identity that could make them a lot happier. You’re absolutely allowed to be a trans woman who dresses however she likes, has broad shoulders, likes her penis, etc. To me, if you want to press the button makes you a woman, then press it. You don’t need to stay that way either, you’re also allowed to experiment and change your label as you see fit. And HRT is magical, if you choose to pursue that route, so you might be surprised at what it does for you.

The “I would never pass” thought is dysphoria, and it prevented me from accepting my identity as well. I eased into my transition, first identifying as a demiboy, then as non-binary, and then I decided to just identify as a binary woman explicitly to counter the idea that would never be “feminine enough.” I had decided at the time that I really liked what estrogen was doing for me, which encouraged me to continue experimenting with more feminine identities.

What is appealing about womanhood to you?

  • source