What an infuriating read, dancing around saying "I'm not saying trans women should be kept out of sports" while simultaneously hammering home just how inferior women seem to be to men when we look at the highest levels of sport.
Are men inherently smarter (chess), more coordinated (darts), more elegant (ice skating), and more agile (gymnastics)? Is it the penis, the testosterone, or some amount of time that makes these things inherent? Do women with PCOS have to start competing with men? Is it how estrogenized someone is, and if so how much is enough and for how long?
Is all of that worth telling trans girls they can't play with their friends? Is all of that worth telling women that men really are the superior gender?
Protection is one thing but comparing what men can do with incredible investment and support structures compared to what most women's sports get is disingenuous at best. This argument is never in good faith. We tried this segregation shit with race before I was born and it's as shit of an argument now as it was then.
EDIT: Their entire post is side-eyeing speed records and going "I'm not saying anything buuuut". If you can't understand why I'm frustrated reading it as a trans woman then just block me and move the fuck on. It's bait made to get people to think it's reasonable to assume that women are not as athletic as men in a post about trans women being excluded from sports with their peers. And all of that side-eyeing implies there's a "man advantage" that women need to be protected from. In context, you can understand what the commenter's heavily implied suggestion is.
If that didn't clarify where I stand: If we're going to have gendered sports, trans people belong with their gender. Full stop. Casually gesturing at gendered professional records as a gotcha or moderate position still implies that you see trans women like me as men.