Moreso wanted to see what a genuinely good player thinks on the matter.
I'm SOOOOOOOOO bad with the melee guys (Warrior + Duelist). Just something about what I need to be doing with them doesn't click. I'm decent with Mage and I've had success with Rogue, but Huntress is the only one I can semi-consistently win with. I'm currently banging my head against making the Cleric work for me. I can usually make it to Dwarven Halls, but last two runs was sniped by a Dwarf Mage that I couldn't even see during killing blow.
I think the big thing is food. Huntress and Rogue get perks with extra food early on which is just enough to help me get my power to a steady state with extra exploration. Mage + Soul Eater is that on overdrive, even if it comes later.
For challenges, I've only ever had success with Bladder Bosses, Barren Land, and Swarm Intelligence (and any combination of those). Literally every other challenge, and I am dead before Boss 1.
Gonna disagree with your take on weapons, though not sure mine is going to be the best. I can't stand slow weapons (spear, glaive), so never equip them. Same for inaccurate (sickle, scythe). I generally prefer accurate (Warhammer, handaxe) over fast (scimitar, sai) over high blocking (shields) over low blocking (quarterstaff, katana), with everything else below that. Wands almost always are preferable to thrown weapons (esp since we can't put comparable weapons into the same stack anymore)(also obv depends on wand - I'll take throwing clubs over a base wand of corruption most days).
Would love feedback on my takes on weapons. And advice on how to better drive characters.