The mouse did not survive interrogation.

Also mouse not pictured.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 12 points 2 months ago (2 children)

Mine would be when I had a 48 bay disk array / JBOD fail on me... badly. After a storm, it killed the larger card that allowed for me to get many of the drives into a PCIe 16x slot, and I was relegated down to only getting ~8 disks per box made from spare hardware. A single box I got 16 going. Add to this mix an SSD for mid-line caching.

These were all running bcache on top of mdraid... One single mount.

Yes I understand how obnoxiously stupid it was to run RAID6 on a 48 disk volume. It was almost all just stuff I could re-acquire over time, not irreplaceable things.

I just HAD to solve this one though.

In come several spare chassis / mobo etc.... get a bunch of drives powered and on /dev/ , move to the next.

A couple spare gigabit switches...

several gigabit NICs...

two explicit paths for each machine...

a bit of iSCSI magic, and one machine now had the physical disks all exposed to it... mdadm --assemble blah blah, bit of UUID chaos...

It's surprising that while a bit speed limited (I think I got just around 110MB/sec reads), it was nicely performant for what a huge mess of wires and disks just strewn out around my rack.

Managed to evacuate all I needed without much issue once I got that going. Now, I try to keep my arrays under 16 drives at a time, or keep a very rigid policy of "I can lose this and don't care" vs "this box gets RAID10 and/or offsite backups nightly".

back up your critical stuff people!

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 7 points 2 months ago (1 child)

    48 disks seems a nightmare in power consumption, failure rate, and overall cabling management....

    What was the total capacity?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 5 points 2 months ago

    Power isn't so bad really. These were all 2tb disks, so ended up with about 40tb total after shenanigans.

    Cabling was atrocious. I'd originally been using several pulled 4 disk SAS backplanes from servers thrown out of my work, just screwed down to some pine boards in a stack.

    Zip ties and sata/sas cables were the rule.

    Overall the drives had 4 small power supplies initially, 300watt iirc. Cheap.

    Somewhere I have an old photo from the wiring during the "rescue" but I have to look around.

    Disk failure was actually not an issue for ages before. A specific thunderstorm with 2 nearby tornadoes is what caught me this time. Before that, the occasional single disk every 6 months or so.

    I still have running arrays using 15 year old disks, many with more than 10 years of that powered on. If you find good models, they can last ages.

  • source
  • parent