In the case of Sekiro, it's very clear-cut: he's a shinobi who's trained in swordfighting and martial arts, so it makes sense that, even though he's not at his prime at the beginning of the game, he's very agile and knows how to fight.

The explanation for Bloodborne's PC being a competent fighter could be that since it's "just a dream"™, they can fight perfectly well. Gehrman and the Moon Presence have no use for a hunter that's incapable of hunting.

But in the case of DeS, DS, and ER? I've got no explanations. Especially in the case of DS, you're on the brink of hollowing - you shouldn't be capable to do anything, really, right?

Maybe I missed something, but I can't answer that question. Thoughts?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 22 points 4 months ago (1 child)

DS1: You got your own private cell in the asylum. Oscar chooses you specifically. So maybe you were extra dangerous before you've gone hollow? But also I've seen lots of "I play Dark Souls for the first time videos"; the player character doesn't seem to have much combat prowess in those. So maybe the player character only learns combat in Lordran?

DS2: You had a long, long journey since you've become cursed. So maybe you've picked up some skills on the way. Going from your happy family life to combat capable warrior.

DS3: See @YewEyeOwe31@lemmy.world answer. "Ash seeketh embers."

Bloodborne: On the one hand you've been chosen by Messengers to be a Hunter or at least for the dream. On the other, the Bloodborne player character feels more like a chosen one from the get go then the other Souls games, where you eventuallym due to your actions in game, become the chosen one. You already know about Paleblood (Moon Presence). You've come from outside, specifically seek out the Blood and you get a summon to Cain Hurst. (Were you a Noble before? You kinda look like one.) So you probably already had combat experience. Maybe not against beasts but you slaughter people just fine.

ER: "Arise now, ye Tarnished. Ye dead, who yet live." Not all tarnished were warriors, but a whole lot were Godfrey's lot. The percentage of combat capable tarnished is probably very high. So maybe you were one of the combat capable ones? (The "Hero" Origin is probably related to Hoarah Loux) I think, Elden Ring is the most vague. You had grace and then you lost it and now you get a bit back. Elden Ring leans more heavily on the "Origins" as Classes are called here and of course a Samurai can fight. It literally says in their description "A capable fighter". But the reason a naked person with a club can fight? No idea… Well, I'm off to bash Margit's brains out with a club.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment