Depends on whether or not you live on stolen land, buy products made with stolen labour, use services run on stolen resources, or enjoy entertainment expressing stolen voices on devices manufactured with stolen minerals, if your life is completely free of benefit from the human exploitation that permeates every aspect of the modern world, then sure I have nothing to say to that.
If not, well there's usually at least a little debate to be had about when and how people should reconcile and recompense such tainted benefits they have but for which they don't feel personal responsibility for because it was someone long in the past or far away.
Just to be clear, I think people and nations do bear responsibility for the legacy of their past/forears. I think the stolen jewels should be returned, but I'm also not in possession of them and I'm not British or from one of the places where the jewels were stolen from.
I also don't think it's realistic for the US government and non-indigrnous population to just return all the land to indigenous nations. So against a debate about when and how.