seriously, when i see questions like OP, my instinct is to be like 'because you're a dumbass'.
but usually it's because their a prescriptive, and they think their use of their language at this particular time, is and always was the only legitimate form of it. and all past or future uses, including their own, are faulty and wrong.
god i remember being in like 5th or 6th grade and arguling about the colloqual use of 'they' with my teachers and getting failed. then in college i got 'lectured' about using 'he' as a pronoun for a singular person was sexist and awful you must use 'he/she' no matter how stupid and weird that looks. and now if you don't use 'they' you're awful because he/she is binary exclusivity or something.
and i bet in 10 years it will be different, yet again, and people will tell you whichever of the previous pronouns or singular pronoun you use are 'highly problematic' because it's not whatever what people have deemed to be 'least problematic'. as if it really matters that fucking much, especially compared to the actual broader themes of the novel in question.