Yeah, the joke doesn't really work, does it? Any decent programmer will have a better shot at fixing a printer, because any decent programmer is good at finding information on the internet and then following the instructions.
Programmers complain about this situation because once people know that we use the computers, they expect us to fix everything for them for free. So, it's just annoying. But I wouldn't sacrifice my life to avoid a minor annoyance, so the joke doesn't really work.
If you're a programmer that doesn't generally know how to find instructions to fix things like printers on the internet and then follow them, then I'm on the side of the guy who wants to shoot them.