Thanks :)
Answers:
1.) Damn, did I miss FS homage elements? Nameless Puppet reminded me, based on the arena and the stance and the flips, a bit of Artorias. Simon looks a bit like Morgott in his initial presentation. I'm thinking about his mid-battle cutscene, but that reminded me of that Michelangelo painting, only here it's not Adam touching God but Simon reaching out to his own divinity, pretty egocentric but on point.
2.) Not entirely. You don't have a magic system or similar and Perfect Guard seems to be what you want to do in most situations. And also though it has many different weapons you can't access them immediately. In other Fromsoft titles you can make a beeline directly to your choosen weapon. For example, I once fought Elemer of the Briar as my first Boss in Elden Ring to get his sword. In Lies of P you have to go follow the linear path until you can pick the stuff up. BUT I haven't seriously tried many of these weapons even early game ones and I haven't really tried item spamming or the Legion Arms. I don't think a build centered on items would be that fun (I don't know how viable that even is.). Legions Arms seemed a bit dull and underutilized, but I just picked up a DLC Legion Arm where you throw disc blade -- very fun.
It probably impacts replayability for me, but on the whole my game knowledge is a bit lacking and even with what I know now I'm probably going to replay it a bit. The promo weapon you get at the beginning with the parry dodge looks quite interesting.
3.) The last 3 Bosses were each uniquely, extremely good. It might be because I'm riding still a bit on a high, but Nameless Puppet might be my favorite. Presentation, difficulty, and the satisfaction you especially get from this fight were quite special. Cutting of halve of their head and their strings and then the craziness that ensues. Oh also the music, it puts you immediatly on edge the moment you cross the threshold onto the arena and keeps you in the fight as it ramps up.
Other than that? I have a soft-spot for Scrapped Watchman. His presentation is decent but nothing to write home about. It's still the early game and we're still ramping up. But this fight made me fall in love with this game: standing in front of a giant boss and just taking his attacks. He has long attack chains that are easy to completly deflect, delayed attacks that are slightly harder to deflect, which also force you to move in phase 2, Fatal Attacks which give you a big attack window when you successfully defelct them. Oh, and he has a grab attack that's not bullshit, this should immediately disqualify him from being a Souls Boss XD. I know he is just a trainings boss and the stuff he teaches is there more extreme in other bosses, but dammit he's a very good training boss. I fought him in the boss rematch feature at difficulty 3 where he has a lot more health, and yes I'm enjoing his fight even more when he can actually take abuse.
Sorry for the long ramble :)
Also I thought Lemmy has numbered markdown lists; hmm it does according the docs, but I only get unnumbered lists.