You might be on the right track thinking it's the monitor, but could also be related to the GPU (assuming it's the same PC/card that tears across different OS's).
If different machines all tear the same way, then I'd say definitely the monitor and the manufacturer may or may not be able to give some insight.
Otherwise, I think we might need some more details about the machine's hardware to be able to give any meaningful advice other than double-checking driver versions and firmware updates, etc.
Things that might be helpful:
- GPU make/model
- Monitor model (the picture at least shows it's an AOC)
- Connection type (HDMI, DisplayPort, USB-C, etc.)
- Have you tried a different connection type?
- Have you tried a different cable of the same type?
- Does it happen on any other monitors?
- Are there other input ports you can try on the monitor? Do they also tear?