Doesn't IINA just use the native macOS video player interface? (I mean, I know it has a lot more on the hood, but that picture just shows the native video player interface.)
So I'm thinking a VLC skin might get you at least partway there?
Mac user here, and I use VLC. Sometimes it uses the native interface, sometimes it uses the VLC one. I'm not sure why, or how it chooses. macOS is kinda janky like that. I'm also relatively new to the platform.