The app I use, Podcast Addict, has given me some pretty decent recommendations from the ones I've subscribed to. I've also had some decent luck search for the keyword "anthology".

I can give you a few more recommendations that are less tipped toward weird, as jumping off points:

• LeVar Burton Reads (Exactly what is says on the tin. Reading Rainbow for adults. Be prepared to hear Geordi say "fuck" once in a while.)
• Myths and Legends (Snarky narrator retelling classic mythology in an accessible modern tone)
• Fictional (Same guy as above, but for classic lit like Shakespeare, Sherlock Holmes, Dracula and Frankenstein)
• Short History Of... (Various bits of interesting history told in narrative form)