I'm glad you understand that, it's hard for me. Swift was an emotional outlet for me for such a long time. I know that what she writes and what we hear isn't exactly her, but it was a good emotional release. The last few albums have felt so... hollow though. Exactly what you said, how can I be empathizing with you anymore, it's completely unrelatable. Either you are singing about real things and that means I can't compare to them anymore (I don't have a private jet or a MSG wedding) - or you're lying about feeling things, and it just makes it harder and harder to connect with.

I like what you said, I'm less Swiftie now and now simple enjoy-er of her music. I don't find myself listining to TTPD or TLOAS, I find myself going back to Rep, Red, folklore, and 1989. I think sadly she's just too disconnected to be truly relatable.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 4 points 2 weeks ago (1 child)

    I know and I understand your struggle. It's feels kind of like she's breaking kayfabe -- previously, she was careful enough with her actions you could think that Taylor from real life was the same as Taylor from her songs, but they've gotten far enough apart I can't conflate them anymore. For many musicians, that wouldn't be that big of a deal, but so much of Swift's empire is built on the sense that she gives glimpses and hints and peeks and clues into her most vulnerable places that I struggle to see how she moves forward. For me, I think I've moved on from being a Swiftie and now it's more that there is a bunch of music I still enjoy, and a savvy businesswoman I'm curious about.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 11 points 2 weeks ago (3 children)

    I've been at such odds with Taylor over the last few years, Combat I know you've known my conflictions. With this it's just another. I know it's claimed so it doesn't go on eBay, but is that really the worst that happens? Is someone making a few bucks on eBay really worse than literally incinerating it all?

    None of that could be reused? Or recycled? High school theaters didn't need new drapes or props? It's so unbelievably wasteful. SinceMidnughts I've been deeply troubled by her actions. She keeps writing songs about being hurt while also literally renting out MSG for her wedding and then incinerating everything. It's hard to describe, actions like this make it harder and harder for me to be a Swiftie.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 1 month ago

    If a person actually did something heinous, I will stop listening to them, watching them, consuming media, etc. Like I don't think anybody supported Lostprophets after their singer was convicted of messing with infants (literally, that happened, he was jailed and then killed in jail over it; the band broke up shortly after the conviction and now almost nobody listens to them anymore even though Rooftops was a certifiable banger).

    But somebody being on a record label whose CEO has done bad things? You already bought the CD, go ahead and keep listening to it. Up to you if you want to keep streaming it or not. But didn't Taylor Swift already go through some shit where she didn't own her music, she had to make "Taylor's versions" of her old stuff, then she won the rights to her old material, and now "it's all Taylor's versions" and that's what the song Father Figure is about? So, why is this an issue if she owns the rights now?

    I keep posting in here, people are gonna stop believing me when I say I'm not a Swiftie. Well, I don't identify as one. I like a lot of different music. Pop has always been a big part of my musical culture and probably always will be, but rock music is my true love in music. Anyway, I personally think she deserves the benefit of the doubt here. You could draw similarities between this and the Ed Sheeran situation, but I don't think it's quite comparable. I'm not saying she's a saint — far from it! — but I think linking her with the genocide is a heck of a stretch.

    At the end of the day, you gotta do what's right for you though. Give people the information, but if at the end of their day, people still wanna listen to the music that takes them out of the bullshit going on all around them... that's their choice.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 month ago

    I think I like more songs by Taylor Swift than I do by the Beatles. I'm not a Swiftie; nor am I a Beatles fan. I do think the Beatles are culturally more significant, but I'm Gen X. They were my generation's band (older Gen X though). "Hate all you like because I like what I like." Or something like that.

    I wouldn't want to hear the Beatles attempt something like "Opalite" or "Ruin the Friendship" — yeah, I pretty much just like "The Life of a Showgirl" (and her older stuff — again, I'm not really a fan) but I also don't think Taylor Swift has the range to do a lot of what the Beatles did.

    And I think that's fine. Neither of them can really do Metallica either, nor should we judge them for it, or judge a fish for not being able to climb a tree.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 3 points 1 month ago

    It's interesting -- Mr Watts clearly wants to say "no" but mostly can only come up with "there's not really a good way to objectively compare," which is surprising because, in music history terms, the time between the Beatles and Taylor is pretty short. More than anything, I think we've had enough time since the Beatles were active for their cultural influence to seep into literally everything, and it will be a lot easier to compare once we've seen whether Swift's oeuvre has the same cultural relevance down the road

    To reach No 1 in the 1960s, The Beatles had to sell hundreds of thousands of copies each week. Records such as Meet The Beatles! and A Hard Day’s Night sold more than a million copies within weeks of release, illustrating the very different commercial environment in which The Beatles operated. For obvious reasons, no artist today sells in anything approaching those numbers, making like-for-like sales irrelevant. Instead the Billboard 200 is nowadays calculated by a complex system that begins with physical album sales and then adds what is called track equivalent albums (TEA) and streaming equivalent albums (SEA) – 10 downloaded song sales, or 2,500 ad-supported and 1,000 paid/subscription audio/video streams are considered the equivalent of one physical album purchase.

  • source
  • Mid watch, but yeah I can say I'm a bit exhausted. I think Midnights is where my Swiftie-ness started waning a bit. Rep, Lover, Folklore, Evermore were honestly really fun eras. Covid Folklore and Evermore especially, we were all alone and the music was exactly what we needed in that moment. Quieter, misty outdoor forest vibes, warm clothes, cozy.

    Midnights was a bit return to form for her which was great, but then she ruined it with the incessant versions and releases. There were always versions but like 2 or 3. Maybe you buy one and then notice the deluxe edition so you pick that up. Midnights had.... 16+ versions in total? Had singles, had special albums, target exclusives, and the freaking clock (in both vinyl and CD). I think I picked up 4 versions in total trying to get the version with "all" of the songs. (She released them each one so you'd think this one would have all of the songs). It all left a very sour taste in my mouth. Right out exploiting the fan's excitement for her music in a really crappy way.

    I'm still a swiftie, but not like I was. I was over the moon and genuinely excited for every era coming out, went to the Eras tour still, but like with this new half release or whatever, I'm just eh. The sad thing too is that the music industry caught on and now everyone is releasing "surprise" albums and multiple versions. It's just enshittification, and it really sucks as a swiftie.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 month ago

    Huh. I just got done listening to the new songs. Patient Zero is the stand out track for me. Feels like it could have gone on the original 2025 release. Cleveland is like the Cancelled! song, it’s not for my generation. The sound is decent but she’s not speaking to me, so it’s mildly entertaining at best. The other two are okay.

    I’m an old school rocker/metalhead from the 70s who listens to Japanese rock now, and I decided to give Life of a Showgirl a chance last year and I was surprised to find that I enjoyed it. I went back to Tortured Poets after a few spins of the new record, but it didn’t grab me the same, so I dropped it. Pop isn’t usually my thing, but it’s also sorta always been there in my life. It’s like I feel like I’m not supposed to like it but I can’t help loving some of it. Eh. It is what it is.

  • source
  • This is interesting, I don't think she's ever really done a B-side beyond her re-records. I've had a theory for a while that 13 albums will be her last, fitting with her lucky number, this makes me wonder if she's staving off #13

  • source
  • [–] [S] 3 points 1 month ago

    Missed opportunity to call the track "The Richest Woman in Babylon"

    A visit to pre-order pages shows that the new songs, besides the already announced “Patient Zero,” are “Cleveland!,” “Pink Clouding” and “Babylon,” listed as tracks 13-16 on the newly expanded version of her 2025 “Showgirl” album.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 3 points 1 month ago

    Is this the finally pro-vax single fans have long been calling for?

    “I’ve been impatiently waiting to tell you that my brand new single ‘Patient Zero’ will be out on September 25 (!!!!!!!!!!!!) and it’s available to pre-order now on my website for 24 hours.”

  • source
  • view more: next ›