The problem with that reasoning is that as far as I can tell, there should never be a version that looks how my browser is showing it. The whole line was added at once.
comments
That would seem to suggest that your browser has cached the old version. Nothing to do with OSM.
Ok even weirder... clicking that link after I created the post...it does display fully when I open it Incognito, but not in my main logged in browsers.
I thought we were all using CoMaps now.
My phone is AOS 5. It auto-detects captive portals and auto launches the browser. From there, just like there are countless ways to fuck up a webpage, there are countless ways to fuckup a captive portal webpage.
Web developers are profoundly incompetent on a widespread scale. I think a lot of it is done by kids who just want to play with the latest HTML frills and latest JavaScript constructs. These are not well-trained professionals who understand the problem of rapidly changing “standards”. They are not taught about backwards and forwards compatibility, and that the latest language frills should be avoided (or guarded by conditionals based on user agent strings). These same undisciplined hackers are apparently writing captive portals.
How new? I thought any phone with a browser could connect.
Maybe your experience could be turned into a feature request for it.
Maybe. I think it may actually be more useful for the OSM front end to improve its editor experience though, so what a user entering data is prompted with is more likely to result in consistent data.
The openstreetmap.org website has a search feature but I think its abilities to search for kinds of POIs are limited. I never use it for that, only to search for names.
You discovered what I meant in CoMaps. Maybe your experience could be turned into a feature request for it.
not clear what you are asking for
On the actual OSM website, on the official OSM front-end. https://www.openstreetmap.org/
That, to me, makes it more than "just" a database.
most of them should have their own user-friendly search features
I tried CoMaps, and my search for "bike parking" seems to have worked perfectly...once I figured out the trick to it (which is to ignore all the regular results that come up, and press the small "view on map" icon). Water seemed...less consistent, though that might be because of some weirdness with how things are classified. It led me to notice there seem to be 3 separate ways taps might be labelled... man_made=water_tap (as well as man_made=drinking_fountain), drinking_water=yes, and (the only one I was previously aware of) amenity=drinking_water.
It's more than a little frustrating that this means that unless every editor is consistently applying all three results, different subsets will turn up on any given search. And this is made worse by OSM's front end, while creating a Point, including "water tap" and "drinking water", depending on what you search for.
edit: wait, I found another related tag. fountain=bubbler
"within OSM" – not clear what you are asking for, OSM is just a database of geographical data
"from any OSM-based apps" – most of them should have their own user-friendly search features, I know OsmAnd does, so you can use that.
Oh nice, that's awesome!
Is there a way to access it from within OSM? Or from any OSM-based apps? It's really cool that that exists as a back-end, but it's not especially user-friendly and I imagine it would be a nightmare to try to find and use on a phone. Especially if you don't know the code for the amenity name, since it lacks any autocompletion/suggestion.
In my case I need geocoding because I am starting with addresses, not coordinates.
Nonetheless, I am amazed to hear that chatgpt can write software like that. I am getting out of touch because I boycott Cloudflare, Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Facebook, etc. So I appreciate the tip. Theoretically I could make use of that for my 2nd step of going from DB to GPX file, but I’ll be tempted to try something like gpsbabel first.
I had the same challenge. I ended up asking chatgpt to write me a Python script that takes a list of coordinates + descriptions and writes a .gpx file. I then import the file as favorites on OSMand.
The script uses the python library gpxpy. It loops through the list of locations, creates a gpx waypoint for each, converts it to XML, and writes it to a .gpx file. This file can then be imported to Osmand.
thanks. Indeed I just checked and Nominatim is still viable. I may just do that.
Though I must say it’s bizarre that such a common need has no software. Everytime I travel somewhere, reviews for interesting restaurants, beer, attractions, etc, only give addresses, not GPS coords. I would expect by now someone would have been driven mad by all the manual entry by hand.
You should be able to run Nominatim in Docker and script that, but if you're looking for a ready-made program for this very specific use case, bad luck.
Yeah that's a pretty good point. That's for the discussion.
It was already said in the thread, it is not really the main focus of OSM. But who cares? I know so many scientists using OSM to collect whatever obscure data. And if you want to look for opening times of your local food bank then that is a valid use case, even if it is a strip club on Tuesdays. I don't want to use google maps for looking that up.
The line to draw where it is too many nodes is a bit fuzzy though. But if one mapper adds 1000 "office rooms" to one building entry, it gets confusing pretty fast. Also, who is going to maintain that? Nobody. But a handful of amenities - do it.
I certainly could do that. I don't know that I'd want to do it if it goes against the community norms and expectations of OSM, though.
I am not sure about that. But regarding the discussion, some of the people involved suggest to place multiple nodes next to each other and that is what I would too. Of course only if the room is shared by let's say, a maximum of 5, but not 1,000.
Thank you! These'll find some use
JOSM is very powerful and responsive to use though it takes time to learn. I have used these resources to figure it out the tool.
Any tips on how to learn to use JOSM? I feel that I should take the leap from iD, but the learning curve is scary
Cool article, I haven’t done it indoors before. Thanks for sharing!
Checkout https://mapcomplete.org/trees . It doesn't have fruit trees specifically though