[–] 8 points 1 month ago (4 children)

GPL doesn't allow for closed source forks. MIT does. You can add extra features without removing compatibility, by adding new flags, etc. Though I do struggle to come up with what premium features cp, mv and rm in particular could be expanded with.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 35 points 1 month ago

    I've said this many many times, but lowering the skill floor for tasks inevitably drops the average quality down. Mathematically provable even.

    There's a reason a lot of the tech made in the 50s/60s/70s/80s was amazing because it was made by the brightest of minds whereas the everday person didn't have the skills to get over the floor. Think moon landing, xerox, and many other analog systems.

    There used to be barriers for entry into these spaces that would ensure effort is done to participate, with low effort garbage being filtered by the minimum impetus. Now that writing code can be "effortless" you end up with a lot more garbage there is no filter for. Same for all skillsets impacted by AI. Graphic design being another big one that comes to mind.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 1 month ago (5 children)

    I'm not sure what you mean by that. They can lock things up behind paywall, if the license is GPL too. As long as any source code of it is online available. Which it is for the Rust Utils, that's not in Canonicals hand. And if Canonical does make changes to their own version, then these are no longer compatible software with the GNU Utils. But the point is being compatible.

    So I don't get the fear here.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 1 month ago

    Oh it's gotten so weird and depressing for me too. Like a lot of people I played with the free demo of GH Copilot when it came out in 2021. I was... not impressed for the most part. Its python suggestions were usually not any better than the standard Python analyzers, though every once in a while it would pop up a surprisingly decent function. Its C and C++ were either hilariously terrible or more likely just non-existent unless I was writing a textbook algorithm for some reason. Then it might be okish, maybe.

    That fall, the company I was working for laid off my entire department, so I spent a few months looking for a job and ended up in management for a few years. The only code I wrote was a few hundred lines of Python to help me manage Jira tickets and I didn't bother setting up Copilot. I'm not sure if the company was paying for it. A couple engineers mentioned that they used it to do a couple of refactors, but nothing much seemed to happen with it.

    Then, right about a year ago I changed jobs to go back to IC engineering at a company that had a strict no-AI code policy. In February I had a crazy work trip where I had three days to bring up some hardware that I had never touched before and script a demo for it. I pulled it off, after a couple of 3AM coding sessions in my hotel room. The C parts were straightforward, but the demo script was a damn mess of some of the worst Python I had written in a long time, due to the time pressure and the fact that I was writing it at 3AM.

    Oh, but also in February the company softened its stance and was allowing AI coding assistance in some very limited ways as long as it fit into whatever our GH budget was. I knew that I would probably never touch the Python again as the real version was in process by someone else in Rust, but just in case I wanted it cleaned up. I figured it would take me a day or so after a good nights sleep to do it the right way. In the airport I asked copilot CLI to refactor my script, as a test, not expecting much.

    Five minutes later it had refactored it into something much cleaner, properly using properties, and other such niceties. It wasn't perfect, there was a sign error in one equation, and there was still some minor cleanup to do but damn. It was good enough that if I was the reviewer I would have thought it was a good first pass and only had a few nits.

    Since then we've all been given a decent LLM budget and told to use it as much as we want. I'm not being told I have to use it, but almost everyone is except for a few of us grey beards. And reviewing the code is terrible, because there is too much of it and it doesn't matter, I'm not actually teaching or working with anyone, just talking to someone who is talking to an LLM.

    Due to some health issues that intermittently leaves me with too much brain-fog to really write code but clear enough to talk about my general knowledge and explain what I want to do, I'm tempted to use them to keep up. And when I do it's so disheartening. They have the judgement of a very junior engineer, but with perfect syntax in every language and documentation level knowledge of almost every subject. But they're just so damn fast at it. Previously, if I gave the kinds of instructions to a junior engineer, I'd expect to hear back from them in a day or three, with a passable first attempt and some interesting ideas to talk about. Now I hear back in five minutes with too much code and no reason to talk with them other than to give a few instructions to clean it up.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 6 points 1 month ago* (8 children)

    Some people don't like Rust language, its eco system and community and the MIT license at all. Combine them and replace core functionality of a popular distribution, that is enshittification for some. Even though the Rust programs are compatible.

    I don't mind MIT license and even do like Rust. But my personal problem with this decision in Ubuntu is, that these Coreutils tools in Rust are not proven yet and finished with 100% bug for bug compatibility and feature parity. So this is a premture decision in Ubuntu for my taste.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 1 month ago

    Yes, I do. Also installed it on my parents computer, not much complain there. I think most people use it because it offers (mostly) newest software without the worry of it changing their system so much it became unusable. Most of them stay because of the small tight-knit community it has. I know I do.

    The again I am biased 😆.

  • source
  • [–] 20 points 1 month ago

    Why the hell would you even search for an report that bug? Surely there are better bug bounties to be had...

    That aside, by all means, use AI if you want to, but don't spam FOSS projects with it like wth. If you want to use AI, check the projects policy first, and if they permit it, look at the code you generated, test it and declare that you used AI so the maintainers are aware.

    And please don't try to contribute code to anything if you don't know shit about coding. Nobody needs your help to write a prompt. I don't know where people get the idea that anyome needs them to tell an AI what to do. If I could just tell an AI and be done with it, I would fucking be done with it.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 2 months ago*

    There's the other side too, though.

    People who never had the time to maintain the projects they created ages ago, because the projects make little to no money in donations so they have full time jobs. Some of them have resorted to LLMs because nobody else is stepping up (and can you even trust randos to take over stewardship of your project? Remember Jia Tan!) and now catch hate for that, when previously they caught hate for not getting enough done.

    I previously never made any of my projects open source because I just wouldn't have time to maintain them anyway. Now I could ease the workload with AI, but I'd rather not deal with either end of the AI issue: I don't want people sending random ass pull requests and bug reports that clearly haven't been reviewed by a human that knows what's up, and I don't want to catch a bunch of hate for using LLMs myself. Not a big loss for the open source community either way, the things I've created are fairly niche tools that you can just pay to get proprietary alternatives that would usually work better, having been in development for longer, by larger teams. Most people won't need them at all though.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 2 months ago

    Yeah they make it sound like it's an EU project or something, but it's just a bunch of private companies banding together to fork OnlyOffice.

    Use LibreOffice, or if you need an alternative to Microsoft Whatever 365 and Google Drive rather than just offline tools, use Nextcloud or something else that suits you (owncloud infinite scale for better performance but fewer features I think?)

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 18 points 2 months ago

    Stop fishing bro. We hate it. The concept sucks. The real world effects suck. The code is mediocre.

    At my current job the offered me a promotion from call center to Testing/QA. Paid very well. Turned it down twice, held out for the actual analyst job.

    Why would I like a thing that takes the fun out of the thing I like? Because I can wOrK fAsTeR?

    You’re just horny for cash like every other brainrotted cynical piece of shit in this godforsaken country and you are trying to justify your position to yourself.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 11 points 2 months ago*

    Don’t forget they’re also taking our hardware and making it so expensive that the only viable option for most people will be a tablet with 4GB ram and 128GB storage.

    “Don’t worry! You can save all your important documents and play all your favorite games on the cloud! Just look at our security certified App Store!”

    They don’t ever want us to see source code again.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 15 points 2 months ago

    Dude, are you me? You said every sentence I wanted to say.

    I fucking hate this AI too. In my (huge) company they're forcing us to use AI and treating the usage of token as a metric of performance. Say, I'm smart like Peter Parker and can move my fingers as fast as The Flash, I can still get a bad grade because I wrote the code myself.

    I just love programming. I secretly enjoy doing my job not only for money. At least I used to. If I had a billion dollars I can give every one a middle finger and continue to work the way I like until they kick me out. But I am not rich in reality. I still need to feed myself and my family, and I'm too old to start over my career also too far from retirement.

    One day I questioned the PR which was raised by a colleague. I can tell immediately that he proxied LLM output to the comment to answer my question. I empathized him, for one thing, that he was forced to work on this part of the project where he didn't understand much just because the management "converted" every one of us to be a "full stack engineer" due to AI-empowerment, and second, he was really overwhelmed by the new workload, again, due to AI-empowerment.

    This is shit, man. In the old days, raising a PR you don't understand equals to showing every one else that you're an idiot, a shameless, ignorant idiot. But not anymore today. We're welcomed to do anything with AI. Low quality? Oh that's because you "didn't use AI properly". Upper management or high ranked "engineers" will show you a demo in a Zoom meeting how they "HARNESS"ed AI to generate their shopping list. "Look? It's 100% correct, so evidently you shall be able to accelerate your speed of work to 1000%."

    Project tech leads apparently focus on quality. Oh, I mean quality of their promotion rate. "If it compiles, if it passes the test (also AI-generate), ship it! What readability? What logic? The fuck you're taking about? This code is Good Enough™!" We don't need to understand the code. We're discouraged to understand the code. Oh, but publicly they will stress, "AI is just a tool and you need to fully understand what your submitting." And they still come after you when the AI-generated code fails in production.

    I also have decades of coding experience, but now it looks worthless. It's worthless at its face value: the corporation is no longer willing to pay for it. AI stole every answer on Stack Overflow, and now it spits out code that looks as if it's written by a human. It's good enough to them. Nobody wants the code perfect anymore.

    It's a crime against human intellect.

    And there are jobs better fit in the tide of AI-replacement: doctors. Doctors have a worklog that's of even higher quality for AI to train on. And if AI can generate correct boilerplates for silly requirements, AI can diagnose most everyday sickness.

    Hey, don't point fingers at me. I'm just trying to talk like AI bros. I swear to god if they don't take legal liability in misdiagnosis, they will push AI doctors in hospitals.

    Yes, they don't take legal liability in business software. "Who cares?" All they will ever face is few of us who do know their crime, and the non existent class action.

    Humanity looks pretty grim. I don't fucking know how I'll survive the world with greedy capitalists with the most powerful robbing tool by far.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›