1
 
 

The Plan

As an introductory subproject, I will be reaching out directly to Lemmy moderators and asking for their experiences establishing and growing their communities. Once compiled, a summary of the experiences will be written up in a living document for current best practices. To do this, I will be contacting moderators in sets of roughly 5-10 at a time. This will allow for constructive iteration in a way that posting on the “new community” subs (as is more or less standard practice) simply would not.

What then?

Once there are enough resources to be useful I'll make announcement posts in relevant communities as well as reach out to the mods of communities like !newcommunities@lemmy.world about being linked in the sidebar.

And long term?

We'll organize a series of activity drives intended to build bonds and strengthen the institutional knowledge of the fediverse. These initiatives may include:

  • Wiki Building
  • Outreach Drives
  • Community Consolidation and Organization
  • Cross-Community Collaboration
  • Housecleaning
2
 
 

The project hopes to directly advance fediverse connectivity and curation by establishing easy to follow best practices for building a digital community from scratch. It is also meant to push the boundaries on current methods and help advocate for the building of institutional knowledge.

This community is very much an experiment, but it is also a place to experiment. With this in mind, if you are considering trying something new, please consider posting your ideas and results. To that end, much of this project will be composed of living documents that will change as we further develop this concept.

3
 
 

Please post your experiences as a Lemmy or Kbin moderator/admin, and I'll type them up into a guide that'll exist as a living document in the sidebar and on the wiki entitled "Building a Lemmy Community From Scratch". If applicable, please make note of what efforts did NOT work as well as what did.


A draft of the document will appear here after a minimum number of responses have been collected.

4
 
 

Anyone looking to deploy a public Lemmy server: plz try to avoid making it general purpose. There are too many general purpose nodes and not enough themes.

It would be useful to have a node that is devoted to travel and navigation and maps. Considering it is no longer possible to anonymously contribute OSM data, it would be useful to have Lemmy communities for OSM work. If I want to create a community for just tracking OSM issues in New York, the temptation would be to create an osm_usa-newyork community. But then someone else or myself might want an osm_usa-california-LA community. Obviously these could really pollute a general purpose instance.

In principle, the OpenStreetMaps project should have their own piefed instance.

5
 
 

The only noteworthy list of forges lives here.

The trend of everyone piling onto MS Github is the classic network effect. People go where everyone else goes. Notice that the Lemmyverse is not a total disaster. The more meticulous brains choose non-Cloudflared decentralised nodes like sdf, slrpnk, europe.pub, etc.

Independent forges that run gitea, forgejo, and gitlab have missed the opportunity to build healthy communities. They just say “here is yet another general purpose forge”. This fails to create an attraction.

If you go down the list of forges, they are either general purpose or they are focused on one specific project.

  • We need themes. Like a node that is for fedi/activitypub projects, or for mapping/satnav/gsm projects. (not arbitrary reg criteria like 0xacab.org gives)
  • We need a dataset with more active contributions. The sdf list is barely noticed despite being the only community dataset of forges.
6
 
 

There is no digital community that can do better than my living room. When adults meet face to face in someone’s home, there is an automatic degree of dignity and respect established even when there are opposing views.

The fedi is on some extreme push to promote mass migration by folks in places like Facebook. It’s a kind of braindead paradigm to just grow without strategy. If your livingroom has culture of a couple dozen progressive freedom fighters who run free software and value things like privacy and human rights, all is good until you open the door to thousands of random normies. They flood in with shitty values and fuckup your missions by dilluting the rich culture that was there.

It is not smart to just cattle-herd masses into the fedi and think your work is done. The mess is just brought to our doorstep. Then what? Consider !ETS@europe.pub. It’s evident just from the voting that a large portion of readers inherently oppose the purpose of that forum. It’s ruined by adversaries because of open access to all while simultaneously coupled with ad hoc concealed voting (you can only see who downvotes if you run an instance).

In principle, we would still need an ETS outreach type of community which is open to all. But then we need a separate invite-only ETS community where we can cherry pick constructive accounts. Just as I would never approach someone wearing a MAGA hat and invite them into my living room, I would not invite an ETS-hostile account into an ETS activism/cult forum. The outreach venue would be used as a recruiting area from which we separate the riff raff from the favorable accts.

With no tooling changes, the only way to pull this off would be for the mod to selfhost, defederate from all, then invite people to register. It’s high effort for the organiser and the participants, it excludes non-self-hosters, and it’s overly isolated.

Lemmy needs to evolve more to solve this.

7
 
 

These communities did not make it into the lemmyverse DB:

  • nolawns
  • asshole_design

Anyone know why, and how it might be fixed?

I don’t suppose there is any problem on the slrpnk side of this because when I list the communities from a logged out browser, the two show up there. So it appears to be a defect in the lemmyverse scraper. I’ve not looked at the code for that but I recall that there is a website where you can enter a community address and a bot adds a subscription does some things in terms of publicity for the community. I’m not sure what it does, but I wonder if that mechanism is connected to the Lemmyverse DB at all.

If yes, then in principle I wonder if slrpnk.net would want to promote its own communities by automatically signalling whenever a new community is created, so community builders need not each have to be informed of it.

UPDATE: I wonder if the answer might be for a bot to automatically post communities on https://ponder.cat/c/communities

8
 
 

It’s hard to find un-enshitified services, even just email. I managed to find a dozen or so ½ decent email providers. But they are only ½ decent. Many are shit in terms of reliability, probably as a side-effect of not being well funded. But then where are the discussions? I Lemmy-search for “onionmail” and only find a dozen hits.

Why is this? IMO it’s because there are just so many shitty options that they drown out the better options. Protonmail is the mainstream alternative to the notorious corporate garbage, but PM is a shit-show in its own right .. CAPTCHAs and other anti-human obsticals.

We need decentralization, but the nasty side-effect is that it spreads an already small crowd so thin we can’t find each other in the universe.