Yeah. They are.. but it basically just is extra profit for banks,
comments
I don't know what the point of the change is.
Before this change we already had a law to say that any surcharge must not be greater than the associated costs (and so it was illegal to be dishonest about the surcharge); and we had a law to say that the surcharge must be clearly advertised in advance of the say (hence all the signs and stickers warning people about a surcharge when it exists).
So from my point of view, that was fair. The surcharge was clearly associated with the cost of using that form of payment. But now, under the new system, the cost of that form of payment still exists but is unavoidable for the customer. I guess there's marginally less thinking involved for people who never pay with cash, but aside from that I don't see a benefit.
The article mentions that the RBA said removing the surcharge would "support a more efficient and competitive payments system". But to me it seems to do the opposite. Suppose for example that a cheaper payment system arose. Previously businesses could have different surcharges for different payment systems, and customers could choose the cheapest. That is no longer the case. So then even if a more efficient and competitive system is created, it will be difficult for it to gain traction. Right?
Also, while this particular surcharge is being banned, others, such as weekend pricing, are not. So it's not like surcharges are gone completely. Only this type of surcharge is being removed.
Stock photo that tap to pay is on the other side of the card.
I think it is reasonable for there to be a requirement for a reasonable fee-free way to get that price (and even an electronic way).
But saying that a merchant's options are to not accept a payment method, or to accept it and pass the fees on to all consumers, is effectively playing into the hands of the big American card networks, and is not a pro-consumer action long term at all.
What happens then is:
- Networks incentivise people to pay using their cards, e.g. by providing small kickbacks.
- Networks start raising the rates on merchants. Merchants pass on the costs to consumers. Consumers who get the kickbacks get a cheaper effective price than cash-paying consumers, but more of the rates go to the network. So cash paying consumers are significantly worse off than if the fee could be passed on, card paying consumers are a bit worse off, and the networks are profiting from it.
- Merchants can't stop offering the ability to pay by the network's card at this point without losing a lot of business.
- Other networks cannot enter the market (and even get pushed out) by competing on price because then they can't offer the kickbacks. Consumers of the new cheaper method would still be cross-subsidising the fees of the other cards, while not getting the kickback.
- Card networks gain power from this duopoly, and use that to decide what types of business are allowed and what is banned or censored, essentially setting the de facto laws of commerce with no democratic input.
This whole thing is one of the late stage capitalism anti-public dynamic that America has (alongside things like the American way of doing tipping) that we should be fighting tooth and nail against. The RBA and Labor should never have allowed this.
Good to have you with us, senator.
Plenty of shops already factored it into their pricing
"When card surcharging ends, the sticker price will be the price that consumers end up paying,"
So keen for this. The number on the sticker should never be larger than the amount I pay. It's that simple.
I genuinely cannot understand the issue and the dismissive attitude some people seem to have about this concept.
Which is stupid unless you eliminate surcharges on the shop side
This just forces sellers to accept the additional costs
I'm looking forward to see what the top books are.
I've also wondered whether some people here may like to say something about books they've really liked an why. If others like the sound of some of the books they don't have to buy them if they can't afford them. Local libraries will order them for their collections and you can read the books for free.
i think what will happen, and this is a real world example for a coffee.. today., the large coffee is listed as $5.20, i get charged $5.28. tomorrow, it will be listed for $5.40
I bet all the prices that end with a .99 will stay that way. The ticket price on the shelf must match the card price at the register.
What actually is the desired result? I figured it's to remove another barrier to people moving away from cash payments
I live in the US. Some cities have banned credit card surcharges. The bans have been wholly ineffective and achieving the desired result. I'll illustrate what happened at my local ice cream shop. This is a real example and not made-up for this comment.
An ice cream sundae costs $4.64. There is a 3% cash discount. So it's $4.50 when paid in cash and $4.64 when paid by card.
This is a credit card surcharge but by another name. And legal according to the rules of Australia's scheme as well. The only real thing that can be done here is to not patronise businesses who impose a surcharge that you think is unfair.
Shoebridge may be that politician and if he is, what a job he has and how many will play dirty against him.
Most of them think Rineharts a great Australian, providing jobs and donating to things.
Both aren’t true; the first is demand of a resource that belongs to the Roy mob and the second is a tax dodge; we’re paying the donations.
Problem is, that doesn’t land a punch. She’s accessible. That matters more.
Attendance? Most of those attending the night the NDIS amendments were voted on in the Senate abstained from voting and most of those were Labor. It’s not an argument unfortunately. Well, it doesn’t land.
We aren’t lacking in those politicians; we’ve probably got the most robust Senate in particular, we’ve ever had.
The problem is the population actually connecting with and supporting these politicians. I mean of course the Greens and some indies like Pocock. Whether it’s lack of decent media coverage or the population itself (which I think is the case just as much as the first), either way they’re being ignored and overlooked.
Labor can’t respond; it’s too unwieldy in the sense it has to do caucus before it can make a decision and it’s as guilty of many of the corruption, jobs for the boys, Zionist support and lobbying as the others are, so it has no solid ground to fight on. Add being inaccessible as people and cruel to the disabled, any pension other than aged (even aged tbh) then the writings on the wall as we see.
BUT DID THE AI SAY SORRY ?????
Nah that wouldn’t surprise me either
That’s American to its core
Just say "Pauline Hanson has been in parliament for 30 years, she's done fuck all. At this point she is the elite." If they say something about her being a battler, say "it's easy to fight when billionaires are playing for your private jet and flights to Italy. "
I did not know that. That's cool.
I think it also acts as a reminder what when you can’t rely on the corporately provided mobile networks, the (privatised) government-built infrastructure is still reliable.
This phenomena has been seen at least in the USA and the UK. And whilst the issue is clear the other side I see is condescension. Calling them names and blaming generations is a sure fire way to underestimate the issue and why it is happening. Its not a surprise when we have counties and communities divided by wealth inequality and politicians unwilling to tackle issues. Cost of living is out of control. People are grouchy and they are seeing it only get worse despite promises from this gov and the last one. So they are looking for another spouting promises. We all know populists wont make a difference and likely make it worse.
I am not saying I know the answer, and I am not saying indoctrination isn't an issue. But its not unexpected, and calling others names or dismissing them as dumb is only likely to push people further to their beliefs.
Is there a politician strong enough to lead through this and call out the media and money feeding and broadcasting hate?
Someone with more photo editing skills than me should make a One Nation poster with that award winning portrait of Gina that she tried to suppress.