Yeah, I'd love to see Graphene develop their own Linux distro for both desktop and mobile, especially since they like to complain about Linux security a lot.
comments
Possible? Yes. Plausible? No, mainly due to the massive ecosystem that Google has built and the fact that maintaining compatibility with newer versions of Android without actually rebasing on top of that newer Android version would be an insane amount of work.
GrapheneOS soft forks Android. I think they're taking about a hard fork.
Unintentional pun 😅
Heartily seconded. I had a couple of false starts, but it's now my launcher of choice. I even supported the dev.
Do the most evil or something like that
I'm not really a programmer so I couldn't really help in that capacity. I could donate but I also should donate to all of the other FOSS software that I use. What would be the best use of my money?
Once there are linux phones you won't have to root them ;).
The mp2 has a smaller battery and no qi2 charging fyi. Also no expandable storage I think, if you care for that. The keyboard also looks smaller.
The click tho lacks an ambient light sensor so no auto brightness. Bit of a headscratcher. Also the mp2 launcher looks quite nice and focused. Software might be nicer there.
Just gave Octopi a spin for the first time in ages. Seems solid - smooth, ad-free. Only thing I couldn't figure out is doing custom backgrounds for icons (e.g., having a colored squircle behind Arcticons icons).
A little more user-friendly than Lawnchair, but less polished than Nova. Not open source, but not (currently) owned by an ad company. It's a nice middleground.
TWRP won't load :( The phone reboots and the error appears again
You do known it's not some big organization right? Have you donated millions to the project to help this along?
Somebody's got to make the phones. You're not going to find a bunch of modders who can manufacture millions of devices, so there's gonna be corporate involvement somewhere along the line. Now that Google is no longer sharing the Pixel firmware, GrapheneOS is working directly with a manufacturer that will.
I don’t understand
It sounds like you don’t understand - TrollAccount69
Username accurate.
It sounds like you don’t understand what the pixel phones are, what graphene is and what open source is.
The pixel phones used to be a reference implementation for an Android handset. A while ago Google decided to try to actually compete in the market and that meant designing hardware people would actually pick over a Samsung or whatever based on the numbers. So they put a chip in the new phone that doesn’t do emte because it makes everything slower.
Graphenes goal is to be the most secure phone os. That means they’re not competing against other Android based software packages, but against ios. It’s a tough row to hoe because whereas apple can develop hardware support for emte and software support across all first party apps and even offer it to developers in a very well documented framework then announce it in a big flashy press conference with the kicker that you can buy the system next month, graphene has to make it a granular switch system that will cause hangs, slowdown and crashes on even the aosp system apps.
Open source hardware doesn’t mean securable hardware. It’s easy to make open source platforms that are fundamentally insecure with no possible software path to remediation.
Now if you want to install some parts of graphene on unsupported devices there’s a fork out there, but it’s pretty stupid to do that since you’re giving up all the security of graphene and gaining all the roadblocks it puts in the way of doing insecure things with apps.
E: spelling
I have never tried it on a tablet, but I really like Kvaesitso on my phone. It's a very customisable search-based launcher.
You can tag and/or rename apps to make them appear in relevant searches, and in tag-based views with the ability to include a single app in multiple categories/views.
Your home screen can include a section of favorites, where you can pin apps + other shortcuts, and order them manually, or based on frequency of usage, or a combination of those. This is where you can switch between favorites and any pinned tag-based views.
The search bar can search for many different things. Apps, contacts, files and the web, of course, but also other sources through various integrations, and custom search engines where you supply the search URL with a variable in place of the search string.
There are even more features to uncover, depending on your user preferences, but this covers the stuff that makes Kvaesitso useful to me.
I switched to lawn chair after nova added ads. No complaints, but my main requirement is the option to get rid of the home screen search bar.
TWRP yes, but in that case it will ask for your pin code, mount and decrypt.
If the partition cannot be mounted, like in this case, it's just plain impossible no matter which recovery.
I hadn't heard of the MP2 until this post. Looking into it, aside from the SD card, the MP2 looks to win in every other aspect for me. I'll be keeping an eye on it.
I'll be running my Pixel 9 with Graphene until I can't, which should be awhile but the MP2 looks like an interesting project. Swapping to a Google-free OS is make or break for me so this seems to tick all the boxes. I can see the physical switch being assignable as something I'd end up not being able to do without lol.
Gonna look into the Minimal OS some more and keep a close eye on this. Thanks for the detailed post.
maybe try booting this or this TWRP temporarily without flashing using fastboot (fastboot boot recovery_filename.img)
(kinda unlikely to be able to directly mount data though, there's one on 4PDA too dated Apr 2024 but it specifically says it doesn't support mounting data)
are you able to obtain the installed version of the firmware or extract stock boot image from device? (if the TWRP above booted, you probably can)
in that case, we may be able to enable adb during boot phase by changing some props on the boot image's initrd, and try logcat'ing to get android properly booting again.
I don't have root and I don't have custom recovery :)
In a way they already do. The trouble is that most big companies want the Google name and PlayStore.
Sorry that I'm not a software developer and cybersecurity and cryptography expert. I rely on the expertise of, for example, those who run the GrapheneOS Foundation.
Clearly, you know better than they do.
Need more Mighty Cats.
- are you rooted?/do you get adb while booting? (few years ago on a custom rom's debug build, but i was able to connect via adb and read logcat and solve the issue it was having while stuck in bootloop and before it auto enters recovery)
- i see you have custom recovery now. can you boot a custom recovery (maybe temporarily via fastboot)?
it should be possible to recover given that you have full unrestricted access to the device and even know the lockscreen password..
seems like it's possible with twrp. btw, i've bootlooped my phone before after using twrp to wipe dalvik cache on a recent encrypted phone (it created an unencrypted dir on userdata iirc, removing the offending directory solved it), so beware and don't do anything that doesn't seem necessary!