Edit: It is now working and I will not be touching anything 🫪

Hello my setup is pretty similar, slskd seems to be updating its port to the one provided by gluetun, and I can download from some users, but with other users i get 'User appears to be offline' in the logs even though soulseek says they are online.

From a second profile on a machine without the forwarded ports, I can see my shares but cant download from them, which means theres a misconfiguration on my end right? Netcat says the port is indeed open.

Anyone have any ideas what I might be doing wrong?

if you want more users you can host headscale instead of using tailscale, users can still connect with the regular tailscale clients

additionally you can use forward auth on your reverse proxy using something like authentik so that users have to be logged in before they can even see the service itself. personally I trust authentik more than I trust all of the individual services which might not have the same level of scrutiny applied to their security. it also has the added bonus of letting your users use SSO if your services support it.

also on FDroid :D

https://f-droid.org/packages/com.nononsenseapps.feeder

I had to install nbfc for proper fan control, other than that everything is smooth