[–] 1 point 1 year ago (3 children)

We need purists like the fsf.

I do not mind that they are purists. On this issue, my problem is that the line they draw between open and proprietary is an entirely meaningless one and yet the act as absolutist about it as everything else.

I do not mind that they are “pure”. I dislike that what they are saying is wrong (inaccurate, not morally wrong).

The operating system and up seems like a totally resonance place to draw the line for Free Software. I mean “software” is right in the name.

Making a big deal about firmware is asking me to pretend I do not know how hardware works and ignore that I am actually using totally proprietary tech regardless. And classifying hardware that is more open as less free just jumps the shark completely. It hear no evil, see no evil nonsense that demands that I never ask questions or look behind the curtain.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 12 points 1 year ago* (1 child)

    The reduction in proprietary hardware that results from those systems is not meaningful in my view while the massive reduction in security and the greater inconvenience matter.

    People have no idea how their hardware works. A card from NVIDIA has not just the NVIDIA drivers but a bunch of internal systems with additional firmware. Even your CPU may have an entire OS on it.

    Hardware that allows its firmware to be updated is more open, not less, even if I currently only have proprietary firmware to load on it. And at least it can be updated. Simply not letting me upgrade the firmware does not magically make the hardware more open. Not allowing proprietary firmware for an open source operating system is just not an idea that resonates with me.

    Would I prefer fully open source hardware and firmware? Yes. I am happy to see these options are slowly developing. In the meantime, we all run our software on proprietary hardware and drawing the line between hardware and software at a less convenient or less secure point is not making me any more free.

    At least, that is my opinion man.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago* (2 children)

    We disagree and you have not addressed my points. So let me stress them.

    corporations are allowed publish a modified version of the software while restricting their code modifications from release to the community.

    Again, totally agree. Under a permissive license , they do not have to share their work if they do not want to.

    Permissive license benefits corporations more than the community.

    How? We both have access to the exact same code. We can license our modifications as we wish including GPL or proprietary. They can do the same. We mutually benefit when we choose the original license.

    As I have pointed out elsewhere, permissive licenses tend to attract more corporate contribution (and collaboration between corporations). That benefits me a lot.

    Google probably has an “extended” version of Clang internally. That is ok with me. I enjoy the substantial code that they do share with me. Same with Microsoft and Apple that collaborate in the same project. I enjoy innovations like Rust and Zig that get built on top. I enjoy FreeBSD that uses it and my main distro Chimera Linux that uses it as well.

    I seem to benefit quite a lot.

    pikachu face when they realize the corporations are legally permitted to take the fruit of their labor from them

    Hard to know how to respond here. Corporations can use you code under any Open Source license, including copyleft (GPL). They do not get one line extra from you because it is permissively licensed.

    I guess I will say “pikachu face” when corporations realize that I can take their permissive code and use it for free for any purpose or even compete directly against them! And I can combine their code with any code I want including proprietary and GPL! And I I think preventing this kind of thing is the main reason Red Hat likes the GPL (you know, the biggest Open Source corporation).

    My time and effort has been lost. The fruit of my labor has been lost.

    How? Real question. How is that statement accurate?

    You put time and effort into advancing an Open Source project. All of that code is still there. It can be modified, studied, enhanced, and shared. What code is available to you and what you can do with it is entirely unchanged when a corporation adds proprietary code on top of it. You have not gained their code, true. But you have not lost yours. And you can keep anything they gave you previously (or in the future). Nothing has been lost.

    When i contribute or make to a Free Software project, i wish for it to benefit the community

    And it does. All “4 freedoms” for example. Permissive or copyleft the same.

    If corporations want to release a software based on modified version of my code, I want a guarantee that the modified code to be available to the community too.

    Ah. Ok. Ya, permissive licenses don’t do that. It sounds like you will prefer copyleft licenses if this is something you want. Fine of course. But it has nothing to do with your other points. As I said, I fully support the idea of copyleft licenses. You should be free to license your work as you wish.

    Do what you want. That is not what everybody wants though. I hope you can respect that.

    Corporations that take things and enshittify them

    Well, if that is what they are going to do, thank God they did not contribute the enshitification to the Open Source repos. We can go on using the Open Source version because it is better and we like the freedom. Sounds like a point in favour of permissive licenses to me.

    all the while they get rich

    How does this happen unless their version is better? And how is it better unless it is their changes that made it better?

    It sounds like what we are really upset about is companies making better software than us and not letting us use it. That sounds like the exact opposite of what you are trying to say happens.

    But again, nobody can take the Open Source away. It is still there untarnished. It may not be enhanced by their efforts but it is not harmed either.

    What you are saying is, if they extend the Open Source software, you do not want the Open Source version anymore. You only want theirs. Because only when you use theirs do you lose any freedom. That is true collectively for “the community”.

    Your choice your prerogative.

    Finally. We agree.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 1 year ago (6 children)

    Almost certainly just somebody that distrusts all business by default.

    I am all for holding business to account but can we not acknowledge that much of what we love in our lives would not be possible without business?

    Kagi is not my friend or anything but they seem like a pretty decent company to me. I have seen no reason to be so cynical about them.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago

    I do not use Fedora and you can consider the opinion above a valid downvote. I just want to weigh in that it seems far too extreme so do not read too much into that.

    I used Fedora in the distant past and try it from time to time. It is fine and completely normal as a distro. Given its support for SELinux, it is fairly secure.

    I agree with the last sentence. Do not be afraid of making the wrong choice. Distro differences are minor compared to the switch you are making and mostly a matter of preference. It is easy to switch once you know more (if you even want to).

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 year ago* (1 child)

    GTK 5 is not yet in the works to my knowledge.

    GTK 3 apps support Wayland natively. GIMP, for example, is GTK 3 and Wayland native.

    GTK 2 is X11 only if you use a distro that even ships GTK 2 anymore. Many do not, including mine.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago*

    The GPL does nothing for MY freedom.

    Freedom to have sex with somebody against their will is not a “freedom” for me. It is subjugation for them. Something does not become a “freedom” simply because it benefits me.

    The right to eat crops grown by others is not a “freedom”. It is an entitlement.

    That said, there is nothing immoral, unethical, or wrong about me growing crops and providing seeds to others on the condition that they share the resulting crops with me or even with everyone. This is a contract and hopefully a mutually beneficial one. All good as long as the terms are known up-front and all parties consent.

    In my view, that last paragraph is the GPL. There is nothing wrong with it at all. However, it does not make either party to the contact “more free”. In fact, you a bit less free in the future when you agree to a contact, because you have to abide by its terms. But at least you got there freely.

    Permissive licenses are not a contract. They are a gift. They make no demands. They take away no freedom at all.

    Both are valid choices. I have no quarrel with somebody choosing the GPL.

    I do not agree that permissive licenses are less free or that the GPL is moreso.

    If it was truly about MY freedom, choosing a permissive license would not upset you.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (4 children)

    Are you willing to provide unpaid labor for corporations?

    When I release code as Open Source, I am providing unpaid labour to everyone. My work is a public good. Like science.

    I welcome collaboration from everyone (including corporations). That is the spirit of Open Source.

    I do not demand it. That is the nature of freedom.

    they are not obligated to release the modified code under the same license

    Agreed

    the community receives nothing back for their labor.

    The community has the source code that has been released as Open Source. That is what results from their labour. They can continue to collaborate and improve it. What they have “for their labor” is totally unmodified. Nothing has been lost. Possibly, nothing has been gained. This is not unique to corporations. The vast majority of the users of the code will contribute back nothing.

    As it turns out, corporations are a major (majority) source of Open Source software and so it is their labor that we all benefit from. This is true for both permissive and copyleft licenses. And, true to form, few of us give anything back.

    [the GPL] obligates that the modified code must be released as GPL

    Agreed.

    So GPL guarantees that the community benefits.

    We disagree big picture.

    First, I see a world with greater freedom as a benefit on its own.

    Second, I think the GPL discourages corporate contribution. Corporations write most Open Source software. The GPL does not prevent natural monopolies in Open Source. Red Hat has enormous influence over Linux as a platform and all of free software as a whole. The GPL does not stop this and may in fact contribute. There is a reason it is their preferred license for the considerable amount if software that they write. In my view, better communities develop around permissive licenses. Just like, my opinion man.

    Third, the GPL shrinks ecosystems and restricts my ability to build on and share code. I cannot combine ZFS and Linux. I could if either one (or both) was permissively licensed. That is a loss of freedom for ME.

    The act of choosing a license political one

    Totally agree.

    I also think that the number one way that corporations profit from code without giving back is to sell it as a service. And the GPL does not help with this at all.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 0 points 1 year ago (1 child)

    Adding to this, Google created Android, wrote all the source code, and released it as Open Source.

    By definition, Google cannot take anything here. It is only a question of what they give way in the future.

    What Google wants is for people to use Google services. So they are making that less and less optional. There is no way for them to mandate this in Open Source and so they are shrinking the size of AOSP.

    Online “services” are the greatest threat to software freedom. What kind of license is used has little to do with it.

    Since this is a “GPL saves the world” thread, how would the GPL change anything? Android is mostly permissively licensed. But let’s assume that it is all GPL. Since we are talking about code Google wrote, nothing changes at all.

    And the Linux kernel is already GPL licensed. Does that mean I can run whatever I want on my phone?

    No. The threats to freedom in the Android space have literally nothing to do with permissive vs copyleft.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›