These sorts of takes are funny to me.
You can oppose Iran's Regime, without being an Islamaphobe, based on Iran's brutal authoritarian theocratic regime and its blatant disregard for individual human rights. But in the West, we can't oppose Israel's brutal authoritarian theocratic regime without being called an antisemite by israeli fundamentalists/lobby groups (basically due to foreign interference).
People who gleefully commit genocide should be condemned, period. Israel's desire to make everyone think that all Jews are represented by the actions of Israel, is to encourage prejudice towards all Jews based on Israel's actions. By trying to force the world/public of Western nations to identify all of Israel's actions as inseparable from the Jewish people, anywhere, they are encouraging antisemitism by virtue of how heinous Israel's current regime's actions are. Jewish groups outside of Israel should be condemning Israel's actions openly, to put distance between the faith and Israel's regime, if they want to quell "antisemitism" abroad. You see some Jewish leaders of conscience doing just this -- Bernie Sanders in the USA, and Avi Lewis in Canada, as two examples. It's too bad it's "antisemitic" to agree and support these Jewish leaders, apparently, if Israel's baloney is to be believed.
Your post attempts to differentiate between Zionists and Jews. Western nations and Jewish lobby groups have decided those two terms are interchangeable, with people criticising zionism facing the same sort of censorship and backlash from Israeli lobby groups, claiming antisemitism. YOU differentiating the terms is all well and good, but so long as ISRAEL is lobbying to try and equate the two, and demanding punishment/consequences internationally for anyone condemning Israel's actions through the guise of "antisemitism", it's not a left-wing problem: it's an Israeli problem. Jewish people have an antisemitism problem, born out of Israel's lobbying to drag them all down into being genocide supporters.
If you really want to push for people to dis-entangle the two, you'd need to have Jewish lobby groups in Western nations, and Jewish faith leaders in Western nations, come out clearly and decisively against what's going on in Israel, and to be very overt about distancing themselves from those atrocities. What we see, outside of a few individual leaders, is a Jewish community that is largely silent and complicit with their faith being used as a shield for atrocities.
all 12 comments