I would wager that this is a popular opinion

Live isn't to listen at their best - concerts are definitely not that, studio is where you get all the takes and engineering you want.

Live is to hear them play more naturally.

I have been generally impressed with the MTV unplugged stuff, and I think that Alice in Chains's unplugged album is one of my favorite albums ever, (Korn did a good one too)but I understand abd generally agree with where you are coming from.

This is not unpopular. I've literally filled out requests to every music service I've ever used to give me a "don't play live songs" button.

"Oh, you like that song from that studio album? Here's 2 live versions of it and 6 other live songs from the same band."

There's 2 types of live music:

• Recording a concert
• Recording at a venue without an audience present

The latter is vastly superior to the former, and occasionally superior to the studio album.

The following are worth a listen.

• Architects' "For Those that Wish to Exist at Abbey Road"
• Poets of the Fall's "Alexander Theater Sessions"

Basically I agree. I prefer studio over live. There might be an exception but yeah in the large percentage of the time, it’s studio

While I generally agree, some of the best music ever performed was done so live on stage. You know when it's their best performance when the audience generally stays silent while they perform.

When the audience generally shuts up, you know it's good.

Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pkgd3tER1yI

Yes, except the Nightwish live album from Wacken 2013.

While I respect what you're saying, music as a whole is so broad that I feel you could only make those kinds of arguments for certain styles of music.

For example, jazz is one notable exception where studio album tracks are pretty much recorded in one take without overdubs and are "live" from the studio. Improvising is essential to the music, and musicians interact with the crowd when live. The crowd response informs the notes bring played in a way that would not be possible in a studio.

Certain types of rock also benefit from live recordings, where mistakes and imprecisions convey a certain excitement to the sound!

I love music, and i also hate live recordings. The exception for me are jam bands. Grateful Dead, Phish, etc... all have incredible and sometimes even better albums compared to the studio albums. But they are the exception. I have also found some festival recordings of sets ive seen to be really good as well. Outside that i will never put a random live song on unless i was looking for it specifically.

I would agree with you 100%, but there are some exceptions, so I’ll agree 98%. Frampton Comes Alive! is the only way I want hear the songs on this album. The studio versions are lifeless by comparison. The musicians are totally feeding off the crowd and the music is better for it. There is a live version of Tom Petty playing Breakdown where the audio mix of the crowd singing is phenomenal. He even says to the crowd “y’all’re gonna put me out of my job”. It’s just fun. I saw Pink Floyd live once and I was mildly let down. They played all their songs note for note, just like the studio versions. No new riffs, no live in-the-moment feels. I didn’t hate it, mind you, but it was a musical performance by professional musicians instead of a live rock concert. Kind of the opposite of what you’ve described.

Generally agree with you, but I have a few selective exceptions and one of my main ones are the 1994 Pink Floyd concert where they - in the video version - bring out the mother of all disco balls during Comfortably Numb

It's a 10 minute long performance and literally half of the time is the guitar crying in beautiful agony. Just go to the 5 minute mark if you want to hear one of the best guitar solos ever made. And this comes from someone who isn't really a fan of long guitar solos.

Another live performance that I prefer over the studio recording is Runrig's Only the Brave. It just feels appropriate that it's a big crowd for this specific song. It feels like a song that should have a whole stadium of drunk, happy Scotsman singing along. It always brings a teary smile to my face, when I listen to this live recording.

I always found live recordings of concerts to have the absolute shittiest mixing possible so that absolutely nothing comes through clearly.

I also remember some Garth Brooks song on the radio of a live recording where Garth literally stops like halfway through the song to tell the audience to chill out because the only thing getting picked up was the crowd.