Lasers make everything better
post
Cool for anyone researching in that field. For the general public this doesn't exist until it's actually happening.
This is c/science, not c/engineering
Yeah, but c/science is popscience not real science.
This is kind of a silly paper, we don't directly hit thermonuclear fuel with lasers, nor do we use x-ray band lasers, like anywhere. Also, you should always take new fusion ideas with a grain of salt. A million fusion startups have popped up in the past year, and 99% of them exist solely to drain venture capitalists of money while they accomplish nothing. Each startup needs to come up with a unique idea that's never been tested to convince their investors they're actually onto something.
Since it sounds like you know what you're talking about, out of curiosity, how do you feel about SPARC?
Tokamak's get their own section at fusion conferences, the rest of us don't go to their talks, and those talks never seem to change. The most important thing to remember is that any success in a tokamak is absurdly irreproducible. Next time you see an article about a tokamak breaking a record, remember to add the context that it failed to set that record the last 1000 times they turned it on, and they didn't really do anything different the time it worked.
Is it the same with stellarators?
Yeah, pretty much. The problem is they're always focusing on their own problems. It's always a hardware problem, and there's no physics to be learned from it, so it's not useful work to anyone who isn't building a similar system. If you pretend that fusion is purely an engineering problem, that would be fine, but we still don't really have a solid physics understanding of everything that goes into a fusion system.
Scrolling, scrolling, scrolling... No info on who actual did the reearch...
Scrolling, scrolling, scrolling,... Finally see a link to a the actual press release...
and it happened in China.
There are soo many amazing breakthroughs happening in China every week, how are they not living on Mars and teleporting yet?
I hate that there is so many bullshit research development reports out of China that my go to reaction is to assume it's a big fucking lie.
China clearly runs pr on their tech stuff, engineering. They do cool stuff I bet but something like this is suspect.
Is it really that big of an issue? I just presume it scales in China. More people, more actual research and more faux science news, but all in the same proportions as in the western world.
Genuinely curious.
Did you even read my last line? I lament that this is my reaction.
Seriously. Your response just makes me think you are not interested in the issue and just want to undermine my statement.
Show me one fucking "breakthrough", in the last two years" that was actually something and did didn't just vanish.
I'll wait.
Or are you just attacking people who are tired of all these bullshit "breakthroughs" that never go anywhere?
The CCP sucks, but this 'everything from China is a lie' mentality is pretty dumb.
they get fudging thier numbers thats why. probably the brain drain during the cold war has costed china alot.
all 32 comments