It was originally supposed to be an anthology series until Netflix execs meddled. That’s what’s wrong with it.
post
I have to disagree that the stakes are never raised. Season 1 the big bad is a Demogorgon who is just a scary monster. Then we add multiple Demodogs to the Demogorgon. Then we add an intelligent creature with the Mind Flayer who controls the above creatures, but he still mostly a monster. Then we add an intelligent human who does all of the above, but hunts children. And now finally in the finale it's all of the above trying to bring the upside down into the real world (technically the plan for season 4, but he won and then "died", so he's doing it again but properly.)
So Demogorgons go from the big bad to just bring minions in the current season. Our main characters are fighting off a dozen whereas one used to be impossible.
Part of the issue, it’s been what 9 years since season 1. The kids are supposed to be in the 10th grade. The magic of nerdy kids saving the world doesn’t work when they look nothing like nerdy kids.
The first season was good because it was simple. The seasons that followed keep trying to build upon the first and improve it. It didn't need to be improved upon, it needed to maintain quality. The show's big moments are cool, but overall it seems like the message has gotten lost. Not interested in the new season at all. I'm just burned out on it. I don't hate it, I just don't care what happens next.
They did the same thing with 13 Reasons Why, except that show did not need to continue. The first season fully adapted the book. The next 3 seasons was just escalated trauma porn.
It would have been so much better if they stuck to an anthology like another user pointed out in the comments. The original characters are mostly insufferable and repetitive…the new ones are really cool but we don’t get to know them properly.
I think it's less that they tried to improve upon season 1 and more like they tried to make it appeal to more people when it suddenly got popular. Season 1 felt very self-contained and genuinely tried to be a horror mystery show, the later seasons seem aimed at teenagers with lots of dumb teenage drama and quirky humor... I remember feeling some tonal whiplash going into season 2 but I guess not that many people noticed at the time.
What’s bothering me is every kid has a metaphor that turns into a plan. Like…once it’s ok…but ffs every plan can’t be based on some dumb thing some kid made up.
Squishy middle? What? Dick door? What are you talking about? They just do the same thing over and over again. Feels phoned in.
Binged all seasons with my gf. Started season 5 and gave up after 2 episodes. We found it utterly boring. I think it just has been too long and they should have called it quits after season 4.
For me season 1 had lots of mystery. What is the upside down? Why does it contain artefacts of our world? How is it all connected?
But the answers were limiting. Vecna made it. It's all vecna.
Had it been another dimension like The Mist or something he tapped into rather than created it would have left more avenues of interest. Imho.
What new girl are you talking about?
Do mean Holly Wheeler?
She has been in the show since S1, and she is great this season.
The timing and pacing of each scene, and dialogue delivery seem off to me
all 23 comments