Windows 10 was good? I missed that consensus meeting. :(
post
When Windows 11 came out everyone was saying that Microsoft finally broke the good/bad cycle.
I always tought it was unusable garbage. Finally I'm being proven right lol
Really??? I never got that, the consensus was it was a pile of shit from the get go. It's why Microsoft had to go extra hard with shoving it down our throats and literally forcing PCs to update.
Idk, I never liked Windows 10. It was better than 8, but I never thought it was good. XP was the last good Windows.
I liked 7.
My timeline of Windowses (that I have an opinion on) would be as follows:
3.1: Decent. Not exactly MacOS or OS/2 but still decent.
95: Good. Solid upgrade over 3.1.
98: Good if unexciting as an upgrade over 95 OSR2.
98 SE: Why did this even exist?
Me: Terrible. They had some good ideas but botched the execution.
2000: Great. My favorite Windows until XP overtook it with SP2.
XP: Good initially, great starting with SP2. The only Windows that technically supported custom themes via a hacked theme DLL.
Vista: Nice try but ultimately bad due to being premature.
7: Really good and actually good-looking out of the box.
8: Utter trash that demonstrated how Microsoft had lost sight of user needs. Also marks the start of the extremely ugly UI period.
8.1: A slight improvement over 8 but not enough to qualify as good.
10: Well, it's better than 8 but that's it. The UI is still butt ugly, Windows Update is so unreliable it might as well be malware, the configuration is scattered randomly over the place... At least it was free.
11: Possibly worse than Me. It's a bit less ugly than 10 but that's it on the plus side. The new features are unremarkable at best and actively harmful at worst and while the UI is less ugly it's also ridiculously slow for what it does.
It's not exactly a tick-tock thing with Windows. It kinda sorta looks like it if we consider 98/SE, 2000/XP, and 8/8.1 to be one Windows each but even then it's a stretch that requires 10's "less bad than 8" to count as "good".
Saying Windows 11 is better looking than 10 is crazy to me, it took 10s awful settings UI and applied it across the system. But I prefer functional UI vs "fancy".
The light mode is not an endless sea of eye-searing #FFFFFF and UI elements are no longer restricted to monocolored flat rectangles with hair outlines. Also, the UI feels somewhat more consistent. That's something.
Mind you, "looks better than Windows 10" is not much of a hurdle to clear.
Hot take: 8.1 is better than 10
for me 7 was peak. 10 was really bad at the start and they brought some 7 things to it and made it alright.
10 wasnt good overall, but it was good versus 8. 11 sucks ass and 12 will too, they will never bounce back in anyway now. It'll just be copilot ai shit.
Which is good, means more people coming to linux.
It was good only for a couple of years after release. It was shittified later.
People always judge "good" windows versions by how they were at end of life. Xp was dogshit it was so bad. 10 was also complete dogshit for rhe first few years.
Excuse my lack of culture, but what's the BOB on the graph before 98 ?
Actually, the "good" Windows was Windows 9, that was never released. So it goes bad 8, godd but non-existent 9, bad 10. Than break of the cycle and bad again - 11.
id still take 7 over 10. can't recall anything specifically in ten that I used.

all 26 comments