Mint.
post
AFAIK xfce desktop environment on top of Ubuntu (xubuntu), or any Linux distribution, is considered the best resource utilization option for old hardware.
I’m gonna suggest what no one else still has but that is the obvious, optimal choice:
Mint.
If it's your daily, sure, use Mint. But you will learn a lot more about Linux if you install Arch the hard way, especially if it's your "fuckin' around PC".
Set up a flash drive with puppy linux. It's relatively easy to do (depending on how much you already know about Linux) and is mostly risk-free (but you can still do damage so always use caution) because it runs entirely in RAM and shouldn't mess with the internal storage drive unless you tell it to. You can use it to copy any desired files without booting Windows and it will probably run on that machine better than Windows ever did. I think that has a 64 bit CPU but there are 32 bit versions floating around the internet if it doesn't. I've seen Puppy Linux versions advertised as being 'so easy your grandma can do it. One project of mine that was fun was creating a Puppy Arcade, a usb flash drive filled with emulators and ROMS but I had issues with some emulators.
Puppy Linux is fun and cute but nothing really ever worked for me the way a normal distro works. But I haven't spent much time on it.
True, it can be tricky for certain things. I suggested it because it fits the OP's a) and b) points better than anything else I could think of. The different versions of it can vary a lot too. Bionicpup worked great on my old eeepc, a netbook with a single core 32 bit cpu, but didn't do well on anything newer. Focal Fossa has worked without issue on everything I tried it on. I wouldn't use either as my main OS, but it can be fun on a secondary system. I kept mine in the bathroom until the humidity from showering likely wrecked it.
How familiar are you with Linux? I recommend lubuntu over xubuntu as it is much more lightweight, at the cost of being more barebones. Also look for guides to make a zram drive for your swap.
The biggest drain on resources tends to be web browsing and writes to disk, so try to minimize these.
I am in a similar position with a 32bit hp laptop, but I think I will try to experiments with a cli-only machine, and go with Debian.
all 12 comments