Tldr surveillance software on loaned school computers can be used by schools to find when students are using lgbtq keywords and potentially out them
post
OK...i dony have kids, but even if you ignore the anti gay/trans aspect of it, this is fucking creepy, right? Like this seems like an unacceptable level of intrusion into a child's life. I find it staggering that this just kind of happened and it wasnt front and center news everywhere! Absolute clown shoes level of crazy.
It's not remote learning that enabled this, it's educational institution malware.
As soon as the kids are the school find this out I guarantee every single one of them will write queer or trans on the laptop, the system will get flooded and they will have to stop
This is so, so fucking stupid.
Am i really supposed such a jarring and complete lack of ceitical thinking ability to believe that this is an issue worth writing an article about?
To explain: of all the monumentally incompetent, illegal, mond-numbingly stupid, and agressively short-sighted things a trenager is inevitably going to type into a school laptop I'm supposed to believe that THIS, this is what is worth writing an article about?
I do not disagree with what the author is teying to say but holy fucking shit what a load of pandering, steaming shit this is.
Getting flagged for being trans is, like, one of a countless number of idiotic things a teenager could do with a school laptop with monitoring software installed that could potentially land them in hot water.
The dangers of normalizing surveillance amongst students are so fucking multitudinous that to highlight any one of them is fuckjng pointless when addressing the root of it covers ALL of them. Including the subject of this article.
TL;DR don't assume privacy on a device you don't own. It belongs to the school/your employer, not you.
I don't think the responsibility is on the children for assuming they have privacy on a school-issued device; surveillance often happens without transparency, and it's reasonable to not expect words like "gay" or "trans" in your writing to automatically be flagged and sent to administrators.
While it's great to educate people on the threats and the ways to mitigate them as individuals, there are policy choices being made here that need to change and the focus should be on how we can achieve that.
true. don't assume privacy on a device you do own, either.
I have set things up to the degree that I can safely assume that my device is private because I severed so many data connections. But most device users can't assume the same of their Microsoft and Google spyware devices. To learn more, check out pewdiepie's more recent videos, he has a good summary of the issues we face as a society.
Last year, a student in Minneapolis was outed when school administrators contacted their parents after a surveillance software flagged LGBTQ keywords in their writing, and schools’ abilities to screen students’ writings are becoming more and more invasive.
...
A recent survey by the Center for Democracy and Technology showed that 81 percent of teachers report their schools are now using surveillance software to monitor students. One particular software used by schools around the country is Gaggle, which surveils school computers and student accounts. The use of Gaggle has resulted in the constant monitoring of students through their Gmail and Microsoft Office accounts, even when at home using personal devices. Gaggle even monitors in real time the content being written by students on Google Docs.
...
Gaggle flags the terms “lesbian,” “gay,” and “transgender” as sexual content that is reported to human reviewers at the company to determine if it should be passed along to school staff. Gaggle’s CEO, Jeff Patterson, defended the policy of flagging LGBTQ content as a means to protect students from bullying.
...
Prior to the pandemic, 43 percent of schools had device distribution programs; now, 86 percent do.
reminder that "parental rights" is the reason why leelah alcorn isn't with us anymore
I don't understand why people keep having kids when everything is getting so much worse for people at every stage of our lives.
Hope is why
Hope through ignorance is just stupidity
what hope?
The same hope that kept us alive as a species through genetic bottlenecks. You have given up, stop dragging those who haven't broken down with us.
Your wireless router probably comes with a guest network feature. Use it.
What does that have to do with the price of fish?? It seems like such scattershot advice that has nothing to do with what's going on in the article. Besides that, most school student age teens don't have access to routers in their home to be able to enable that anyway.
Yeah, I realized that shortly after I posted, so I updated the post to point out that this wouldn't do anything against a device that had spyware installed to flag a user for what it incorrectly deems as objectionable behavior.
PS to mods: I'm not a bot, but I do post like one in the trailers community while I build out automation to do that work for me. Everything I post is 100% made by me. I'll get appropriate permission from instance ownership before I turn anything on.
Remote Learning Accidentally Introduced a New Danger for LGBTQ Students
Their laptop was given to them by their school, and it contains software that flags any student writing that uses, among other terms, “queer” or “transgender.”
The software must have slipped and fell into the laptop.
In 70 years on this planet, I would have thought we'd put LGBTQ+ and racism to rest. I look forward to a day when being LGBTQ+ is as boring as being heterosexual. America could solve about 50% of it's problems by using this one simple trick: Mind your own fuckin' business. My sexual proclivities should only come into discussion if you're sitting on my lap. Otherwise, piss off.
They are useful tools the rich have to keep us divided and fighting each other rather than them.
I'll go further: humanity could solve 99.9% of its problems if people would mind their own fuckin' business.
Those are not proclivities. Those are normal tendancies that multiple species share. ;)
They need to be taught that anything they use their school email address to log in to or anything on their school laptop can be seen by others. That's the important lesson missing here.
They also need to be taught how to log out of their school accounts and use a personal account while on a personal device and not doing homework.
This can really hurt students who consider or are unaware of privacy risks while on the internet or on a school device.
it is the schools device and there free to do anything with it. sad to see schools are not a safe place for students but its just how it is now. and the parts about student personal devices should be against the law.
edit: actually fineshed reading the article
The USA, a bastion of free speech and the self-pronounced land of the free - except if you're different.
top 17 comments