Buddhism and Critical Psychology I’m not a psychologist or an academic, so I’m aware that I lack some of the terminology to express what I mean. This might therefore come across as naive or poorly informed. English is also not my first language.
I have a South Asian background and a history of trauma. Over the past few years, I’ve become somewhat interested in critical psychology, and I also know a few people who are very interested in Buddhism.
Sometimes, however, I find certain approaches within Buddhism difficult to reconcile with a critical psychological perspective. And yes, I probably need to read much more about Buddhism before making any strong conclusions.
At times, some of the ideas I encounter strike me as potentially similar to what is described as spiritual bypassing, although I realize that this may be an oversimplification, and that Buddhism encompasses many different traditions and interpretations.
Whenever I talk to someone close to me and Buddhism comes up, I find myself struggling to understand human relationships and human existence primarily through a Buddhist framework. It sometimes seems to me that there is a strong focus on the individual, the self, and one’s relationship to one’s own thoughts, suffering, and inner experience.
But what about the social and material conditions surrounding a person?
What about war, violence, poverty, oppression, abuse, or a child who grows up experiencing these things? These are not simply matters of how an individual relates to their own thoughts or inner suffering. There are external realities, power structures, relationships, and social conditions that can profoundly shape a person.
So I’m wondering: Has anyone here studied both Buddhism and critical psychology, or perhaps works as a critical psychologist/therapist and has engaged seriously with Buddhist philosophy?
I’d be particularly interested in perspectives that go beyond the usual “Buddhism is about inner peace” type of explanation. I’m trying to understand whether there are Buddhist approaches that explicitly address social structures, power, violence, trauma, and interpersonal relationships, rather than primarily focusing on the individual’s internal experience.
Originally posted by u/Quirky_Bat_9281 on Reddit.
Top comment by u/yvrtoyyz
Not a therapist, but I've done some reading on this myself. Here might be some good starting points.
"Suffering" is a bad translation of the original Buddhist concept, dukkha. To illustrate, here's an easy read on the concept of the first arrow vs. second arrow. This ties into the DBT concept of radical acceptance. While I have my critiques, Linehan based DBT on skills taught in Buddhism. These skills are 'self-help-y', ultimately the goal is simply to improve your ability to act skillfully and compassionately.
Thich Nhat Hanh helped popularize engaged Buddhism, which taught how to apply Buddhist principles and values in activism. TNH also promoted the idea of inter-being.
Ironically, Buddhism relies heavily on the idea of interdependence of all things and the inner peace comes from understanding the idea that there is no "self". This helped me to actually stop self-blaming so much and recognize that relationships, power structures, negative events, etc. can and do naturally have impacts on me and others.
Let me know if this is helpful at all, happy to discuss/explore further.
TLDR; There's a lot of white-washing of Buddhist concepts. Read the OG stuff.
no comments (yet)