Alt text: If you ask a topologist what their house is like they start counting windows, doors, and chimneys.

source

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 4 points 1 year ago (1 child)

Hmm. Your comment gave me something to think about. Now I've thought about it and done some research... I still think the comic is right, because it specifies a 4-holed sphere.

Here's my thinking:

A sphere with two holes can be stretched into the shape of a drinking straw (or a donut, or a coffee cup). That same shape can be stretched into a disc with a single hole: one hole in the sphere becomes the outer boundary of the disc.

Likewise, a disc with three holes has the same topology as a sphere with four holes. (Or a dress, or a T-shirt.)

So yeah, you can say that a straw has one hole and a dress has three ... but only when you're counting holes in a disc.

This page shows the sphere/disc thing visually, and uses clothes as examples:

https://seattlemathmuseum.org/math-in-real-life/clothes-holes

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment