you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 3 points 5 days ago* (last edited 4 days ago)

Hmmm looking into it further... I don't think the Victorian Socialists are exclusively a Socialist Alternative run body (they have independent members, such as Daniel Lopez who says here that he specifically resigned from SAlt, but is still running as a VS candidate). Various sources point to them not being exclusively run by SAlt. VS run an open caucus with democratic centrism (with other caucuses and factions participating, such as the Communist Caucus).

"Unlike Socialist Alternative, VS is not organised as a sect." -David Passerine (Communist Caucus) Source

I think Socialist Alliance's main complain appears to be that Socialist Alternative are too focused on election time... and they feel this restricts all-year-round involvement (from what I'm reading here).... but given that people like Purple Pingers is out there all year around, I think this doesn't ring true.

I suspect Socialist Alternative might just be a bit more demanding of members to be disciplined in running for election. I've heard them described as cult-like and protective of their organisation/role... but those might also be qualities that have resulted in success? So hard to argue with their contributions (they're over represented at the organisational level, but under represented in total membership.... so they do lots of the work, but people are free to vote for other organisers/ideas). Victorian Socialists don't seem like a blank extension of the "cult-like" mentality people claim about SAlt... they seem distinct/different enough, whilst also benefiting from the dedication put in by SAlt members.

  • source
  • parent